Quote Of The Year

Timeless Quotes - Sadly The Late Paul Shetler - "Its not Your Health Record it's a Government Record Of Your Health Information"

or

H. L. Mencken - "For every complex problem there is an answer that is clear, simple, and wrong."

Saturday, May 19, 2012

Weekly Overseas Health IT Links - 19th May, 2012.

Note: Each link is followed by a title and few paragraphs. For the full article click on the link above title of the article. Note also that full access to some links may require site registration or subscription payment.
-----

Expert Panel: OpenMRS Implementers: Experiences and Lessons Learned, May 14th to 18th 2012.

Started by A/Prof. Terry HANNAN on 07 May 2012
Many clinical organizations are working to implement an electronic medical record (EMR) or electronic health record (EHR) to digitize their work and improve the care they can provide. However, many have questions about how to choose an EMR and how to implement these programs.

To answer these questions, we have been fortunate to obtain access to the knowledge resources of four experts in the field of e-health and OpenMRS implementation. OpenMRS is an open source EMR with a community of hundreds of implementers and developers, that have implemented this system in over 130 sites in 50 countries (
http://openmrs.org/about/locations/), including the US, South Africa, Germany, the Philippines, and Chile. Further, both the Rwandan and Kenyan governments have chosen OpenMRS for the implementation of their national eHealth infrastructure.
-----

Telemonitoring helps to lower blood pressure rates

By danb
Created May 11 2012 - 11:59am
With an estimated one in three adults in the U.S. suffering from high-blood pressure [1]--which, when combined with stroke, costs the U.S. healthcare system $156 billion annually--it is imperative that better methods of caring for the condition emerge. Telemonitoring research unveiled this week [2] at the American Heart Association's Quality of Care and Outcomes Research Scientific Sessions 2012 in Atlanta provided a glimmer of hope for such patients.
Patients who received telemonitoring help and regular follow-up support from a pharmacist were more likely to have lowered their blood pressure than patients receiving traditional care, according to researchers, led by Karen Margolis, M.D., of Bloomington, Minn.-based HealthPartners Research Foundation.
-----

Public vs. private HIEs: Room for both?

By danb
Created May 11 2012 - 1:25pm
While private health information exchanges are non-reliant on government handouts and thus, slightly more self-sustaining, according to an article [1] published in this month's Journal of AHIMA, they also, according to some, undermine efforts of public HIEs, which aim to connect providers for the greater good, rather than for greater profits. So the question remains: Is there room for both?
-----

ONC Seeks Input on NwHIN Governance

MAY 11, 2012 12:05pm ET
The Office of the National Coordinator for HIT has issued a request for information on establishing a governance mechanism for the emerging Nationwide Health Information Network.
The mechanism will include common rules expressing technical, privacy and security, and business practice requirements to create a consistent trust baseline for stakeholders, according to a PowerPoint presentation from ONC. “In the absence of national guidance, states and other private sector stakeholders/consortiums are beginning to develop state/consortium-unique and potentially conflicting governance approaches to electronic health information exchange.”
-----

5 reasons data inaccuracies occur in EMRs

By Michelle McNickle, Web Content Producer
Created 05/10/2012
Studies have shown in recent years that the quality of data in many electronic medical records is often not very good. According to Peter Witonsky, president and chief sales officer at iSirona, this is largely due to simple inaccuracies that occur more often than we think.
"A lot of these fall into the same category, in my mind, but it's different ways of getting to that category," said said Witonsky. "That latency of data is terrible. We have customers, prior to us, with eight to 10 hours in latency of data, and that's not uncommon. It's not the end of the world, but there are tons and tons of examples of what latency of data will do to decision making on the other side."
-----

Doctor Fights Back Against Online Complaints

Joe Cantlupe, for HealthLeaders Media , May 10, 2012

On neighborhood Internet community bulletin boards, like the ones I frequent, people write their joys, concerns, and gripes about everyday life, whether it's about a house painter, or the local school system. They also rave about doctors they are crazy about, and occasionally nix those they definitely wouldn't recommend.
But the physician talk is only sporadic, and generally not too specific. There seems to be an understanding that the physician probably lives nearby and might see the negative comments.
Wednesday, May 9, 2012

Health Information Technology in the United States:Driving Toward Delivery System Change, 2012

From the abstract: "Health information technology (HIT) has become central to health care reform policy-making due to its potential to improve efficiency and increase the quality of health care in the United States. Adoption of these technologies has remained a priority of the federal government as evidenced by incentive programs enacted through legislation, including the American Recovery and Reinvestment Act of 2009 and the Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act.
-----
Friday, May 11, 2012

ONC Must Go Further To Achieve Flexibility in its 2014 Edition

Of the three tenets of meaningful use -- adopt certified electronic health record technology, demonstrate core and menu set requirements, and report on clinical quality measures -- adopting certified EHRs has proven more complicated than most providers anticipated. In an iHealthBeat Perspective last year, we discussed some of the specific challenges that health care providers -- in this context, both eligible hospitals and eligible professionals -- have faced in adopting certified technology. One of the most significant challenges was the Office of the National Coordinator for Health IT's December 2010 clarification that required providers to possess each of the certified EHR's capabilities, not just those that they intended to use to demonstrate meaningful use. 
-----

California Providers Reach Out For EHR Help

Unusually large number of Californian docs ask state's regional extension center, CalHIPSO, for help meeting Meaningful Use regulations, but few have actually achieved MU so far.
By Ken Terry,  InformationWeek
May 11, 2012
More than 7,700 healthcare providers have enrolled in the California Health Information Partnership and Services Organization (CalHIPSO), the largest health IT regional extension center (REC) in the nation. This is significantly more than the 6,200 providers who were expected to participate when CalHIPSO started two years ago with $33.2 million in federal grants.
The target population for RECs includes rural and safety net providers, as well as primary care doctors in practices of 10 or fewer physicians. Currently, CalHIPSO's membership is divided about evenly among small private practices, community health centers, and public hospitals and rural providers, said CalHIPSO CEO Speranza Avram in an interview with InformationWeek Healthcare. AdTech Ad
-----

Experts: Use patients to reduce errors in electronic records

By mdhirsch
Created May 10 2012 - 10:07am
Giving patients better access to their electronic health records is not only part of Stage 2 of Meaningful Use. It's also an effective way to improve the quality of the data, according to a panel of experts who spoke on a recent webinar [1] hosted by the National e-health Collaborative [2], a public-private partnership established by a grant from the Office of the National Coordinator for Health IT (ONC) to foster national health information exchange (HIE).
"You can't proofread your own stuff. You have to have a second pair of eyes," said speaker Dave deBronkart, co-chair of the Society for Participatory Medicine.
-----

Despite challenges, disruption, experts sunny on HIE market

By gshaw
Created May 10 2012 - 12:08pm
In spite of turmoil, the health information exchange (HIE) market grew more than 40 percent in 2011, according to a Chilmark Research report [1].
"In little over a year we have seen several vendors exit the market, several others enter and the acquisitions of Carefx by Harris and MobileMD by Siemens. We also saw Microsoft pull completely out of the clinical market by turning over all its HIT assets (except HealthVault) to the new joint venture with GE, Caradigm," Chilmark notes in a post [2] about the report.
-----

New ONC dashboard tracks nationwide HITECH progress

By Mike Miliard, Managing Editor
Created 05/09/2012
WASHINGTON – The Office of the National Coordinator for Health Information Technology (ONC) has  launched its new Health IT Dashboard, offering an interactive trove of data related to grants programs, regional extension centers and other measures of health IT adoption.
Chock full of maps, charts and graphs, the dashboard presents comprehensive information about ONC innovation grant programs, and it offers detailed presentations of performance data for programs such as the Health IT Regional Extension Centers and Community College Consortia to Educate Health IT Professionals.
"The release of the Health IT Dashboard is a significant milestone and we are glad to welcome the website as a tool for delivering key data to ONC's stakeholders and the interested public," said Victor Lazzaro, ONC's performance officer and director for the Health IT Dashboard projects.
-----

Telemental Health Dramatically Cuts Psychiatric Hospitalization Rates

Caroline Cassels
May 9, 2012 (Philadelphia, Pennsylvania) — Providing telemental health (TMH) services to patients living in rural and remote areas dramatically reduces psychiatric hospitalization rates, new research shows.
The first large-scale assessment of TMH outcomes showed that patients' psychiatric hospitalization utilization decreased by about 25%.
-----

6 keys to the future of analytics and big data in healthcare

By Michelle McNickle, Web Content Producer
Created 05/08/2012
A recently released report by Ewing Marion Kauffman Foundation proves the value of big data is certainly something to take seriously. And as more organizations create plans to make better use of and leverage their big data, Joe Petro, senior vice president of healthcare research and development at Nuance Communications, believes the industry is on the brink of seeing some pretty remarkable things as a result.
Petro outlines six keys to the future of analytics and big data in healthcare. 
1. Organizations are "drowning in information, but dying of thirst" at the same time. According to Petro, one CMIO at Nuance sums up the current state of big data eloquently: "When you're in the institution and you're trying to figure out what's going on and how to report on something, he says you're dying of thirst in a sea of information," he said. "And what he means by that is, there's a tremendous amount of information but a big data problem, and the issue is how do we tap into that to make sense of what's going on?" This question applies not only to the patient, Petro continued, but also to the government's plans in regard to disease and population management. "The issue is it isn't organized," he said. "It's a mixture of structured and unstructured data, and what's going to happen over the course of next several years is the government is imposing a tremendous amount of information for folks to report."
-----

ONC privacy and security guide offers 10 steps for MU

By Mike Miliard, Managing Editor
Created 05/09/2012
WASHINGTON – ONC's Office of the Chief Privacy Officer (OCPO) has published a "Guide to Privacy and Security of Health Information," which aims to help physicians, nurses and IT staff better understand how the safety of patient data is essential to meaningful use of electronic health records and mobile devices.
Earlier this spring Healthcare IT News reported the results of a study from HIMSS Analytics and Kroll that showed security breaches are still widespread in healthcare – despite increased attention paid to patient privacy.
The "HIMSS Analytics Report: Security of Patient Data," suggested that, despite increasingly stringent regulatory activity with regard to reporting and auditing procedures, most providers were prioritizing compliance with the rules over actually bolstering their own organizations' security protocols.
-----

NHS IT has chance to be a world leader

4 May 2012   Chris Thorne
Katie Davis, the current head of IT for the NHS, has given the NHS an 'eight, possibly' score of confidence in the NHS becoming a world leader in healthcare IT within ten years’ time.
Speaking in a question time panel at the end of the 2012 Health Informatics Congress in London yesterday, the managing director of NHS Informatics at the Department of Health, was asked how likely it was that the UK could gain such a position.
“That’s a tough question, it would be unrealistic to say we will definitely have a world beating IT system in ten years because we are in a period of huge change,” Davis told journalist Nick Ross, who moderated the event. “
-----

HIPAA changes likely to put onus on vendors to protect data

By danb
Created May 9 2012 - 11:04am
Health IT companies that deal with patient data are more likely to be on the hook for data breaches when highly anticipated changes to the Health Insurance Portability and Accountability Act are announced within the next few months, according to an article posted to Mass High Tech.
-----

KLAS: Providers Have Big Plans For BI Solutions

CIOs Are Looking for More from BI Solutions
Slightly more than half of healthcare providers are planning to buy or replace their business intelligence (BI) solution in the next three years, according to a new KLAS report, which found that those who are in the market are seeking a robust solution.
The report — Business Intelligence Perception 2012: A Wave is Coming found that providers are looking beyond clinical and financial data needs and targeting solutions that offer predictive analytics, data modeling, forecasting, trending, and other functionalities that will help them get meet regulatory requirements and position their organizations for participating in HIEs and ACOs.
-----

JAMIA: PHR med review tool reduces discrepancies

Concordance between documented and patient-reported medication regimens and reduction in potentially harmful medication discrepancies can be improved with a PHR medication review tool linked to the provider's medical record, according to a Journal of the American Medical Informatics Association article published online May 3.
Medication-related morbidity and mortality is estimated to result in $76 billion in total costs annually, and adverse drug events are estimated to occur in one-quarter of ambulatory patients. Of these, 11 percent are considered preventable.
-----

Computer-Based Screening May Reduce Teen Substance Abuse

Last Updated: May 07, 2012.
A computer-facilitated screening and provider brief advice system for primary care can increase adolescent receipt of substance use screening across a variety of practice settings, according to a study published online May 7 in Pediatrics.
MONDAY, May 7 (HealthDay News) -- A computer-facilitated screening and provider brief advice (cSBA) system for primary care can increase adolescent receipt of substance use screening across a variety of practice settings, according to a study published online May 7 in Pediatrics.
-----

Help! My Shrink Tried To Friend Me

Doctors with bad social media etiquette.

Back in college, a friend of mine was seeing a therapist. It was a small school, and the therapist was always in the commons drinking coffee and smoking with the students, including my friend. It was a little sketchy even back then, but she was sure it would end after college. It hasn’t: More than 20 years later, the shrink is all over Facebook. She’s “liked” my friend’s business Facebook page, she frequently comments on the alumni page, and she’s become Facebook friends with other classmates. My friend is not happy that this ex-therapist—someone with whom she shared deeply personal issues from a difficult time in her life—has taken advantage of easy online access to her, even if it’s virtual. Old classmates you never liked all that much lurking on your page are one thing, but a medical professional who knows your inner secrets is a whole other level of invasion. In my friend’s words: It’s creepy.
-----

AMA seeks to remedy 'cumbersome' Stage 2 rules

By Mike Miliard, Managing Editor
Created 05/08/2012
CHICAGO – Arguing that changes "are necessary to ensure that the meaningful use program lives up to its intended purpose," the American Medical Association on Monday submitted its comments on proposed Stage 2 criteria to Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services Acting Administrator Marilyn Tavenner.
Joined by 98 state and specialty medical societies, the AMA sought more flexibility in its formal comments on the proposed rules for Stage 2 of the Medicare and Medicaid electronic health record incentive programs.
Citing the "technological and other challenges" many doctors are experiencing as they work to meet meaningful use, AMA officials offered suggestions for "synchronizing the multiple health IT and quality programs currently underway" in a bid to drive up physician participation.
-----

mHealth poised to explode, expert says

By Diana Manos, Senior Editor
Created 05/07/2012
MORTON, IL – Mobile health, or mHealth, is poised to explode over the next decade, says Chad Udell, managing director of Float Mobile Learning, a mobile learning consulting, strategy and research firm based in Morton, Illinois.
“Wellness programs and at-home health monitoring are just exploding right now,” Udell says. “So much of this is due to the fact that people like mobile. Mobile is with us all the time. It has facilitated so much bi-directional communication, and it gives us constant connectivity in a very and meaningful way.”
-----

Report Posits that Decentralized Data Analysis Increases Privacy Safeguards

MAY 7, 2012 4:46pm ET
A recent report from the Center for Democracy and Technology examines decentralizing analysis of health data to better protect privacy.
“As the digitization of health records makes it easier and more cost effective to share and analyze health data, policymakers and businesses are increasingly looking to use health data for secondary purposes--uses beyond that for which the health data were originally collected,” according to the report.
-----

Politicians block state drug tracking database bill to protect privacy

By danb
Created May 8 2012 - 1:58pm
Despite calls for a drug tracking databases to help curb prescription medication abuse, not everyone is convinced that such databases are the right way to go. For instance, Missouri state Sen. Rob Schaaf helped to block a bill [1] pushing for the creation of a drug tracking database, calling it an invasion of privacy.
"This bill causes every citizen to be forced against their will to give up their ... personal information about the controlled substances they are prescribed by their doctor," he said, according to [2] the Associated Press. Schaaf, who is also a family physicians, was part of an eight-hour filibuster against the bill.
-----

Somerset plans 4,000 telehealth users

4 May 2012   Lyn Whitfield
NHS Somerset is planning to monitor the symptoms of 4,000 people living with long-term conditions over the next three years, using technology from Safe Patient Systems.
The programme will be one of the largest roll-outs of telehealth monitoring outside the national whole system demonstrator project, and will focus on people with chronic obstructive pulmonary disease, congestive heart disease, and diabetes.
The Safe Mobile care System, which was developed by a consultant surgeon, David Morgan, works by providing patients with a touch-screen mobile phone-style device, which is programmed with personalised care plans from its web-based application software.
-----

GP prescribing 'could be improved by IT'

2 May 2012   Fiona Barr
Better use of computer systems in general practice could reduce errors in GP prescribing, which are currently found in one in 20 prescriptions, a major study has recommended.
An investigation of prescribing in general practice commissioned by the General Medical Council, found most errors were classified as mild or moderate, but one in 550 was judged to be serious.
It recommends a greater role for pharmacists in supporting GPs, more effective use of IT in general practice, and extra emphasis on prescribing in GP training to address the issue.
Professor Sir Peter Rubin, chair of the GMC, said GPs were typically very busy so it was important to make sure that prescribing was given the priority it needed.
-----

Climbing the Meaningful Use Mountain

Scott Mace, for HealthLeaders Media , May 8, 2012

Not long before I joined HealthLeaders, I found myself engrossed in a subject that involved technology and medicine, but took place far from the operating room.
The subject was mountain climbing. And the parallels to health system leadership are many. I'll explain. Scaling one of the world's tallest peaks remains an expensive endeavor. Not all calamities can be foreseen. Risks are high. Public exposure is great. (These days, many mountaineers tweet their way to the top.)
In each endeavor, technology continues to make great strides, but often requires a leap of faith, and months, if not years, of preparation. And yet, the best expeditions are guided by seasoned veterans who've often learned the hard way, through failure.
-----

E-prescribing up by 75% in 2011, Surescripts says

More than half of office-based physicians prescribing electronically
May 4, 2012 | By Alaric DeArment
ARLINGTON, Va. — More than one-third of prescriptions were sent electronically in 2011, the country's largest e-prescribing network said.
-----

Will Regina Holliday Become Health Care's Rosa Parks?

The protest organized by Regina Holliday over a patient’s right to access their medical information is not quite the same magnitude as agitating for integration in 1950s-era Alabama. Yet there are intriguing similarities between the crusade Rosa Parks launched then and what Holliday is attempting today. Both involve a refusal to accept second-class status and a resolve to push back against entrenched institutions.
Parks’ story is well known. Her refusal to surrender her seat to a white male passenger on a Montgomery city bus in December, 1955, prompted her arrest and a sustained bus boycott by outraged black residents. That boycott’s success propelled a young Martin Luther King, Jr. to the forefront of the fight against segregation. Parks eventually came to be known as the “mother of the modern day civil rights movement.”
-----

Virtual doctor’s visits catch on with insurers, employers

By Phil Galewitz, Kaiser Health News

Tired of feeling "like the walking dead" but worried about the cost of a doctor's visit, Amber Young sat on her bed near tears one recent Friday night in Woodbury, Minn.
By Todd A. Buchanan, for USA TODAY
Amber Young at home with her husband Bill and sons Cameron, 6, and Brody, 8, as she prepares dinner.
That's when she logged onto an Internet site, run by NowClinic online care, a subsidiary of UnitedHealth Group (parent of health insurer UnitedHealthcare), and "met" with a doctor in Texas.
After talking with the physician via instant messaging and then by telephone, Young was diagnosed with an upper respiratory illness and prescribed an antibiotic that her husband picked up at a local pharmacy. The doctor's "visit" cost $45.
"I was as suspicious as anyone about getting treated over the computer," said Young, 34, who was uninsured then. "But I could not have been happier with the service."
NowClinic, which started in 2010 and has expanded into 22 states, is part of the explosion of Web- and telephone-based medical services that experts say are transforming the delivery of primary health care, giving consumers access to inexpensive, round-the-clock care for routine problems — often without having to leave home or work.
-----

Markle Foundation releases new policy guide for health IT

By Diana Manos, Senior Editor
Created 05/07/2012
NEW YORK – The Markle Foundation has issued a new resource to help organizations implementing health IT navigate governance, individual consent, procurement and other areas related to secure information sharing.
The May 3rd release of the new Policies in Practice updates a similar resource, the Common Framework, released by Markle in 2006. Since then, the health IT landscape has dramatically transformed, Markle officials said. The passage of the HiTECH Act, new waves of regulation and increased investment in and adoption of health IT have brought both challenges and opportunities.
-----

IHI puts the spotlight on innovators pursuing better care

By Bernie Monegain, Editor
Created 05/07/2012
CAMBRIDGE, MA – Hospitals, physician practices and health plans across the country are boosting care – and saving millions – by employing quality measures, information technology and plenty of innovation. A new book tells the stories behind the successes.
Maureen Bisognano, president and CEO of the independent, nonprofit Institute for Healthcare Improvement, and Charles Kenney, a healthcare journalist put the spotlight on seven of these organizations in a new book, “Pursuing the Triple Aim.”
The triple aim they refer to is better care, better health and lower costs.
-----

Digging into docs' love-hate relationship with EHRs

By gshaw
Created May 7 2012 - 11:41am
If you ask a doctor what she hates about electronic health records, you're liable to get an earful. But it turns out that docs have something to say when it comes to what they love about EHRs, too.
Interviews [1] with a number of practitioners in American Medical News reveal some themes.
Docs hate that there's no guaranteed increase in productivity, that EHRs often add extra steps to their workflow and send them hunting for difficult-to-find data, for example.
-----

Physicians and social media: Follow the money

By kterry
Created May 5 2012 - 1:03pm
Physicians would not be well advised to use social media to connect with patients [1], said family physician Dike Drummond in a recent commentary posted to KevinMD.com--one of the top social media sites for doctors. His view is evidently similar to that of the majority of his colleagues: while 84 percent of physicians [2] use social media for personal reasons and 67 percent for professional purposes, few of them communicate with patients on Facebook, Twitter, or other social sites.
Some experts say that physicians are reluctant to use Facebook or Twitter for patient contact because of privacy or malpractice issues [3]--and that's undoubtedly true in many cases. But Drummond observed that physicians are not paid for going on social media sites with patients unless they have concierge practices. Furthermore, he pointed out, studies show that a third of physicians feel burned out on any given work day. So the extra time and effort required to interact with patients on social media might be the straw that breaks the camel's back, he argued.
-----
Monday, May 07, 2012

EHR Vendor Contract Controversy Persists

Like many industries that evolve in a somewhat unregulated marketplace, health IT has enjoyed a bit of a Wild West existence, albeit within a highly competitive environment. The scene is changing. Products' merits and their pivotal position within the care delivery system -- particularly with regard to patient safety -- face increasing scrutiny, as quality improvement advocates, policymakers and even the health IT community press for more transparency and, potentially, regulation.   
One hot-button issue is electronic health record vendor contract language that some claim impedes safety improvement. Two types of clauses have landed in the limelight:
  • "Hold harmless" clauses that require purchasers to indemnify vendors for errors, injuries or malpractice claims arising from use of the product; and
  • Clauses that prohibit users' open disclosure of identified product defects, glitches or hazards.
The American Medical Informatics Association, in a November 2010 position paper, and the Institute of Medicine, in its November 2011 health IT safety report, called for eradication of such clauses on the grounds that they run counter to public policy and safety-improvement interests.
-----

GOODBYE, PAPER

Electronic health records are being used in hospitals and doctors’ offices. So how are they doing? Do the E-records protect and promote patient safety?

Globe Staff / April 30, 2012
The patient who had come to see Dr. Eduardo Haddad had complicated problems — he was obese and diabetic with pulmonary hypertension. As Haddad reviewed the 50-year-old man’s medications, reading from a long list saved in the patient’s electronic health record, a window popped up on Haddad’s laptop. Two of the drugs, when taken together, could make the patient drowsy, it warned.
Haddad, an independent nephrologist in a two-doctor office in Lawrence, calls himself “old-fashioned.” He still keeps a bank of paper records in the receptionist’s office, but the electronic records system he uses each day is advanced. There are tools to screen for adverse drug interactions like this one and prompts to help him make choices about tests and treatments.
-----

Enjoy!
David.

Friday, May 18, 2012

An Important Status Update on Heath IT In the US. More Than Worth A Download.

The Markel Newsletter pointed me to a really interesting report:
Wednesday, May 9, 2012

Health Information Technology in the United States:Driving Toward Delivery System Change, 2012

From the abstract: "Health information technology (HIT) has become central to health care reform policy-making due to its potential to improve efficiency and increase the quality of health care in the United States. Adoption of these technologies has remained a priority of the federal government as evidenced by incentive programs enacted through legislation, including the American Recovery and Reinvestment Act of 2009 and the Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act.
Since the inaugural report of Health Information Technology in the United States, released in 2006, the authors have found slow, steady increases in the level of adoption for physicians and hospitals throughout the United States. Now, as these incentive programs and other reform initiatives begin implementation, they continue to track the progress of the nation’s health care system toward universal adoption of electronic health records (EHRs). Mirroring the emphasis at the federal level on the use of this technology in a way that has the greatest potential to improve the overall quality and efficiency of care, this report expands on their previous analysis by investigating health care providers’ readiness to meet program requirements and explores the role of HIT in other health care reform initiatives." Read more
The entry is found here:
Here is a more direct link

Health Information Technology in the United States

Driving Toward Delivery System Change, 2012

Published: April 2012

Get full text or downloads

Health information technology (HIT) has become central to health care reform policy-making due to its potential to improve efficiency and increase the quality of health care in the United States. Adoption of these technologies has remained a priority of the federal government as evidenced by incentive programs enacted through legislation, including the American Recovery and Reinvestment Act of 2009 and the Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act.
Since the inaugural report of Health Information Technology in the United States, released in 2006, the authors have found slow, steady increases in the level of adoption for physicians and hospitals throughout the United States. Now, as these incentive programs and other reform initiatives begin implementation, they continue to track the progress of the nation’s health care system toward universal adoption of electronic health records (EHRs). Mirroring the emphasis at the federal level on the use of this technology in a way that has the greatest potential to improve the overall quality and efficiency of care, this report expands on their previous analysis by investigating health care providers’ readiness to meet program requirements and explores the role of HIT in other health care reform initiatives.
This page is found here:
If you want to know in 70 or so pages just where the US is in e-Health in 2012 this is for you! It covers the incentive program for EHR adoption, Health Information Exchange, lessons learnt and a whole lot more from a group who really know what is going on.
Vital stuff with some lessons for OZ about bottom up and top down that are worth thinking about carefully!
David.

Thursday, May 17, 2012

ABC Radio National Covers The Roll Out Of the NEHRS (PCEHR) and The Report Is Pretty Sceptical.

The following segment was heard on The World Today at around lunchtime.
12:18:00 17/05/2012
The Australian Medical Association says 'all singing, all dancing' patient controlled electronic health records won't be available, when the new system starts in July. The AMA's president Dr Steve Hambleton says he suspects most practices don't have the right software to use the system. The Government says it's already paid millions to help doctors upgrade their systems
 You can download the audio for the story from this link.
As always there will be a transcript available - probably by the time you read this.
This report seems to follow up on a couple of speeches at a conference made by the Health Minister and the AMA President. Here is a report of what went on.

E-health rollout likely to be slow: Labor

  • From: AAP
  • May 16, 2012 5:17PM
FEDERAL Health Minister Tanya Plibersek has admitted the take up of electronic health records will likely be slow in the first few years.
People can register to have an e-health record from July, however, doctors have long argued the opt-in system could prove problematic.
"There are only so many times doctors are going to stop and look to see if their patient has opted in and given them access to their personally-controlled electronic health record (PCEHR)," Australian Medica Association (AMA) president Steve Hambleton said.
"If doctors were to find most of their patients had a PCEHR they would be more likely to keep using the system."
Dr Hambleton and Ms Plibersek both addressed a Committee for Economic Development of Australia (CEDA) health forum in Melbourne.
The minister used her speech to spruik the benefits of e-health, including a reduction in medication mix-ups and less duplication of clinical tests.
But Ms Plibersek said while the digital "foundations" would be ready by July 1 the e-health journey wouldn't be completed overnight.
"It's not just a matter of flicking a switch and away you go," she told the forum.
"We've always said the rollout of the national e-health system would be in gradual, carefully managed phases."
More here:
There is really nothing new in all this - rather we have final confirmation that come June 30 what we will actually have is a PCLES (Personally Controlled Largely Empty Shell)  and that the AMA is still of the view that the approach being adopted won’t do much for years - if ever.
It is worth noting that as far as foundations are concerned it is by no means clear they are finished either. Who I ask has obtained their NASH certificate and token to facilitate access to the system and who has received software from their provider to access the system?
Worse than all this just where is the roll-out plan that covers the period after June 30, 2012? It really is about time this information was public - it should have been months ago.
One really does wonder just why it is taking $476M + $35M up to June 30 to get to such an inconclusive outcome. I am sure the Senate Estimates Process will be seeking answers to just that question in a week or two.
David.

Wednesday, May 16, 2012

It Is Time For the Readers Of This Blog To Do Some Work And Help With Australian E-Health Openness and Transparency.

As I reported a few days ago we are in the twice yearly process of Senate Estimates Committee hearings.
This is an opportunity for Senators to ask bureaucrats and responsible Ministers probing questions on just what is going on behind the scenes in their Department and to try and winkle out some information and accountability.
Both NEHTA and the E-Health Team from DoHA attend and are questioned for about 1 hour. It is likely this will be happening in the sessions between Monday  28 May to Thursday, 31 May 2012.
It would be fair to say that my experience of having watched the live feeds of the last few years of these Q & A sessions suggests the bureaucrats are really first cousins of Sir Humphrey Appleby of ‘Yes Minister’ in terms of their capabilities to talk for the hour and say essentially nothing despite the best efforts of those asking the questions to have some light shone in the dark internal holes of the Department.
From this I have concluded that what is needed are precise questions that require a specific number or a simple yes or no answer to gain the maximal information for the listeners and readers of the Hansard transcript.
You challenge is to provide me with some questions for DoHA or NEHTA which are well informed and which will actually elicit some information we would all like to know.
Obviously your suggestions will be available for use by the Opposition and the Greens both of whom find to some degree they struggle to actually get answers that are useful from these Committee hearings.
I will be able to pass any suggestions on to both teams for consideration as well as providing a copy to the committee Chair representing the Government via the blog.
Thinking caps on - well informed questions that might flush out hidden abuse, fraud or malfeasance are especially welcome.
Thanks in advance.
David.

Tuesday, May 15, 2012

It’s Time To Check What We Were Promised With The PCEHR Two Years Ago.

Here is the press release - (I have highlighted the important and not delivered bits in italics):

Personally Controlled Electronic Health Records for All Australians

Australians will be able to check their medical history online through the introduction of personally controlled electronic health records, which will boost patient safety, improve health care delivery, and cut waste and duplication.
11 May 2010
Australians will be able to check their medical history online through the introduction of personally controlled electronic health records, which will boost patient safety, improve health care delivery, and cut waste and duplication.
The $466.7 million investment over the next two years will revolutionise the delivery of healthcare in Australia.
The national e-Health records system will be a key building block of the National Health and Hospitals Network.
This funding will establish a secure system of personally controlled electronic health records that will provide:
  • Summaries of patients’ health information – including medications and immunisations and medical test results;
  • Secure access for patients and health care providers to their e-Health records via the internet regardless of their physical location;
  • Rigorous governance and oversight to maintain privacy; and
  • Health care providers with the national standards, planning and core national infrastructure required to use the national e-Health records system.
Benefits for patients
Patients for the first time will be empowered with easy-to-access information about their medical history - including medications, test results and allergies - allowing them to make informed choices about their healthcare.
They will be able to present for treatment anywhere in the country, and give permission for health professionals to access their relevant history at the touch of a button.
Patients will no longer have to remember every detail of their care history and retell it to every care provider they see. Parents will not have to remember the vaccinations their child has had, and doctors and nurses won’t have to thumb through paper records.
Patients will control what is stored on their medical records and will decide which medical professionals can view or add to their files, meaning privacy will be strengthened.
A personally controlled electronic heath record will have two key elements:
  • a health summary view including conditions, medications, allergies, and vaccinations; and
  • an indexed summary of specific healthcare events.
Benefits for health providers and the health system
Poor availability of health information across care settings can be frustrating and time consuming for patients and health professionals alike.
It can also have damaging effects on a patient’s health outcomes through avoidable adverse drug events and lack of communication between health care providers.
About 2-3 per cent of hospital admissions in Australia are linked medication errors. It equates to 190,000 admissions each year and costs the health system $660 million.
About 8 per cent of medical errors are because of inadequate patient information.
Clear, quickly available information will reduce such incidents, avoid unnecessary tests and save scarce health resources.
Implementation of personally controlled electronic health records
Personally controlled electronic health records will build on the foundation laid by the introduction of the Individual Health Care Identifiers later this year. Under this, every Australian will be given a 16-digit electronic health number, which will only store a patient’s name, address and date-of-birth. No clinical information will be stored on the number, which is separate to an electronic health record.
Implementation will initially target key groups in the community likely to receive the most immediate benefit, including those suffering from chronic and complex conditions, older Australians, Indigenous Australians and mothers and newborn children.
This investment includes funding for the first two years of the individual electronic health record business case developed in consultation with all states and territories and the National Electronic Health Transition Authority (NEHTA).
Subject to progress in rolling out the core e-Health infrastructure, the Government may consider future investments, as necessary, to expand on the range of functions delivered under an electronic health record system.
Reforms to take health system into 21st century
A national e-Health records system was identified as a national priority by the National Health and Hospitals Reform Commission and the draft National Primary Health Care Strategy. It was also supported by the National Preventative Health Strategy.
The Government’s reform plans in primary, acute, aged and community care also require a modern e-Health infrastructure. It is a key foundation stone in building a health system for the 21st century.
A personally controlled electronic health record will not be mandatory to receive health care. For those Australians who do choose to opt in, they will be able to register online to establish a personally controlled e-Health record from 2012-13.
The release is here:
Here is a link to the points about all this I made at the time:
If ever there was a fantasy wish list that has not been delivered this is it. Any review of the areas in italics reveals that gross exaggeration was the name of the game. This sentence is just wonderful...
“The $466.7 million investment over the next two years will revolutionise the delivery of healthcare in Australia.”
What? Nothing has changed that anyone can detect and right now we have an advertising blitz running saying what they imagine well be and asking for you to be reminded to register for your own record when they are ready.
This extract from a 2010 interview is telling:
MELINDA HOWELLS: Nicola Roxon says half a billion dollars is a big commitment.

NICOLA ROXON: Governments of past have put off making the decision to do this and our focus will be absolutely on these stages and of course there is business plan for the stages that can come after that. This investment, however, will give the momentum to taking electronic health records that step closer to reality in Australia.
Full interview here:
So back in 2010 there was a plan, funding was contingent on actual progress none of which is evident but some (lesser) funding has emerged and thing were to be revolutionised in two year. Shows how silly it is to say stuff like this when you don’t understand what you are saying.
If there is actually a plan (especially a newly modified one - which I doubt) - it would be good to see it to see if it has any more chance of being delivered.
At least the new minister seems to realise things were rather over-egged two years ago and is easing back on the expectations. She was doing that job really well until this astonishing outburst in her most recent release:
“eHealth will support a better healthcare experience for patients and improved support and decision-making for healthcare providers. It has been estimated that net benefits from the current PCEHR program will reach $11.5 billion over 15 years to 2025.”
The release is here:
Show us the reports that confirm this we all say in unison. Given the NEHRS design has never actually been implemented anywhere in the world it is clearly a piece of fantastical thinking on the part of an advisor or a straight out ‘porkie’. You choose.
David.

Monday, May 14, 2012

Weekly Australian Health IT Links – 14th May, 2012.

Here are a few I have come across the last week or so.
Note: Each link is followed by a title and a few paragraphs. For the full article click on the link above title of the article. Note also that full access to some links may require site registration or subscription payment.

General Comment

Clearly the big news of the week was the recent Federal Budget. It seems overall that over the forward estimates e-Health (very broadly defined) are being cut back just a little.
Go here to see the overall picture. (E-Health is about 1/3 way down the page)
My sole remaining question is to wonder just what the $33.4M for the present financial year is to be spent on. Seems like a lot for about six further weeks. I guess we will find out in due course.
-----

Transforming healthcare IT

May 7, 2012
Healthcare is the fastest growing segment of the Australian economy. Costs must be lowered and outcomes must be improved. Paper records are incomplete, inaccurate, inaccessible and isolated and growing silos, with loads of old computers.
Transferring patient records to electronic forms is the future of healthcare and is seen as a way to reduce out-of-control healthcare costs while improving patient care. Hospitals today in common with most other organisations depend on a wide range of documents for the day-to-day accomplishment of work. These documents take on a myriad of formats, both paper-based and computer-based.
As Bill Gates said in the Road Ahead “We always overestimate the change that will occur in the next two years and underestimate the change that will happen in the next 10”. He’s right but currently we are on the cusp of many things. Online collaborative services and content management systems today are essential.
Modern information technology offers unprecedented opportunities to improve healthcare for Australians promising better quality at a lower cost. Health systems must change dramatically to address many challenges over the next decade. Health IT solutions will improve the quality and efficiency of care but only if physicians and hospitals implement and operate them effectively – better enabling free and easy exchange of information among departments and organisations.
-----

$1bn in health cuts go to other priorities

ALMOST $1 billion will be cut from health programs to fund new commitments and help drive the budget back into surplus, leaving some patients facing higher costs and even affecting some signature policies such as the GP Super Clinics.
Some health program cuts, such as for dental services or for e-health incentives, will be ploughed back into new initiatives in the same areas, such as the redirection of $183.9 million in tele-health incentives into a $233.7m commitment to continue developing standards for the electronic health record system due to launch on July 1.
But the budget papers have been peppered with numerous other cuts, ranging from less than $1m to more than $100m, and collectively worth nearly $700m, where the money has been reclaimed without being specifically earmarked for similar activities.
As well as the $370m saving created by winding back the medical expenses tax offset, $96.5m will be saved by again trimming the Extended Medicare Safety Net, which reimburses 80 per cent of a patient's out-of-pocket costs incurred outside hospital once their spending has reached a given threshold.
-----

Budget cites privacy concerns in dumping anti-fraud measure involving Medicare and the PBS

THE federal government has dumped an anti-fraud measure that would see data matching between Medicare and the Pharmaceutical Benefits Scheme due to privacy worries.
Budget 2012 papers reveal that the federal government has decided not to proceed with the system that was being designed to try and catch out fraudulent citing 'privacy implications'.
Dumping the data matching facility will free-up funding of $4.4 million given to the Department of Human Services in the 2009-2010 federal budget.  
-----

E-Health, PCEHR, Nehta: Losers in Australia’s Budget

Posted on May 9, 2012
Summary:
If E-health and PCEHR will save $11.5b by 2025, why is government underfunding it in this budget?
ZDNet, usually an accurate source of information, has allowed itself to be fooled by data in the budget papers relating to e-Health in Australia. The article claims that e-health gets a $233m boost. The budget papers do say that Government will provide $237.7 million over three years to implement the National e-Heath program. But some is capital and some is money already due but not yet delivered for this financial year. And it is not a boost.
-----

Patient care sacrificed for ‘artificial surplus’, claims Opposition

10th May 2012
THE Opposition has joined general practice’s criticism of the federal budget, saying it risks sacrificing vital patient care for an “artificial surplus”.
Shadow parliamentary secretary for primary healthcare Dr Andrew Southcott accused Treasurer Wayne Swan of “ripping” $83.5 million from general practice’s role in cervical cancer screening, diabetes care and immunisation by effectively reducing the number of practices that receive incentive payments.
“The cuts to primary care are just another example that Wayne Swan and the Labor government are more worried about providing their artificial budget surplus than providing patient care,” Dr Southcott said.
-----

Work to begin on pharmacy and pathology specs for PCEHR

Written by Kate McDonald on 10 May 2012.
The National E-Health Transition Authority (NEHTA) has issued a call for expressions of interest from community pharmacy software vendors to join a new panel to work on incorporating PCEHR specifications into their software.
The deadline for expressions is June 4, with a shortlist to be announced after July 2. The community pharmacy software panel is the third to be established, following the GP desktop software vendors panel and the aged care software vendors panel. Expressions of interest for the latter were published in December last year, although there is no final decision yet on which vendors have been chosen.
-----

Gravy train on the move

  • by: Suse Dunlevy and Karen Dearne
  • From: The Australian
  • May 12, 2012 12:00AM
PHARMACEUTICAL companies have been forced to curb their extravagant entertainment of doctors, but e-health is emerging as the latest gravy train in the health sector and this time it's the taxpayer footing the bill.
A crackdown on telehealth incentives in this week's budget came after the government found some doctors had hooked up Skype cameras to their computers and conducted telehealth consultations with colleagues in the same practice so they could claim a $6000 telehealth payment.
New rules will now impose a minimum distance of 15km between practitioners before the incentive can be claimed and doctors will have to perform 10 consultations before they get the full payment.
Yet the biggest e-health gravy train is being run by the body in charge of setting up the new personally controlled e-health record, the National E-Health Transition Authority (NEHTA).
-----

Budget a boon for e-health

Government funding of $233.6 million for personally controlled electronic health records (PCEHRs), announced yesterday in the 2012 Australian federal Budget, will boost both the health and ICT sectors in Australia, according to the Australian Information Industry of Australia (AIIA).
The budget included $161.6 million to continue operation of the PCEHRs, with a further $4.6 million to be used to maintain safeguards for privacy-related aspects of PCEHRs.
-----

Sticks and no carrots as govt pushes GPs on e-health records

9th May 2012
THE government will bar GPs who don’t participate in the personally controlled electronic health record system from receiving e-health PIP payments, while stripping money from the existing telehealth incentive program to fund it.
Last night’s budget announcements finally answered the oft-repeated question of how the National e-Health Transition Authority would continue to function and how the PCEHR would be rolled out once the current funding for both projects expired on 30 June.
The government will spend $233.7 million on e-health over the next two years, contributing $67.4 million to NEHTA and $161.6 million to operate the PCEHR and another $4.6 million on privacy and security safeguards for the system.
-----

Qld rural doctors question federal budget

By Sam Burgess and Francis Tapim
Updated May 10, 2012 05:47:10
Country doctors says the federal budget has ignored the needs of medical professionals living in regional Queensland.
The Federal Government has committed $35 million towards improving 'e-health' in the state's regions.
However, the Rural Doctors Association of Queensland president, Ewen McPhee, says e-health is no substitute for more doctors and nurses on the ground.
-----

GPs to pay, says AMA

10 May, 2012
David Ramli
Australia’s peak medical body has slammed Labor for cutting millions of dollars from incentive programs, claiming this could push general practitioners to the wall.
In the budget the government said it was raising the bar for GPs wanting to get money from its practice incentive programs (PIPs), which are designed to encourage doctors to adopt new ways of treating patients.
The move is set to save taxpayers $83.5 million over four years as Labor guns for a budget surplus.
-----

AMA lashes out at cut to incentives

Mark Metherell
May 10, 2012
Child immunisations could fall as a result of cuts in incentive payments to doctors, the Australian Medical Association has said in comments that have drawn the wrath of a patients' group.
Doctors should not need to get special payments to immunise children, Carol Bennett, the chief executive of the Consumer Health Forum says.
''It would be a sad reflection on doctors'' if they were not prepared to ensure the best interests of their patients without extra payment, she said. ''This is supposed to be core business,'' she said, for which doctors received the standard Medicare payment, plus up to $6 for notifying the national immunisation register.
-----

Budget 2012: $467m prompts just one in ten

Just one in every ten Australians is expected to opt for a personally controlled electronic health record (PCEHR) over the next two years, despite the Government’s hefty $467 million investment in the programme.
From July this year Australians will be able to sign up for a PCEHR, but according to figures contained in the 2012-13 Budget papers only 500,000 people are expected to opt into the system in the first year. By the end of the second year around 2 million people are expected to have signed up.
Even four years out fewer than 7 million people are expected to have opted into the system suggesting that health professionals will have to continue to run a dual system supporting patients with and without a PCEHR for years to come.
-----

Health professionals pleased with budget

FRANCES THOMPSON
09 May, 2012 04:00 AM
HUNTER health experts are glowing with good news about what they say is real and new investment in the sector.
They have few complaints other than a cautious rider that the budget fine print will need to be checked closer in coming days.
Chief executive of Hunter Urban Medicare Local Mark Foster said he was surprised at the level of new investment.
Dr Foster said the most attractive item was the $200million in new funding for electronic health (e-health) records over two years.
-----

Use e-health or lose incentives, GPs told

GENERAL practitioners will be required to participate in the electronic health records system due to launch on July 1 or lose an existing incentives package worth up to $50,000 a year per practice.
The move, which is part of a wider tightening of criteria for GP incentives that will save $83.5 million over four years, is accompanied by a staging or scaling back of other payments designed to encourage doctors to get involved in tele-health, which the government has spruiked as one of its signature reforms.
The tele-health measures will save $190m over five years by introducing a distance requirement for the first time, meaning the site where patients are having the consultation -- usually a GP surgery -- will have to be at least 15km away from the specialist whose advice is being sought.
-----

Budget 2012: e-health gets $233m boost

By Josh Taylor, ZDNet.com.au on May 8th, 2012
The government's national e-health program is set to get a $233.7 million dollar boost in this year's budget ahead of the 1 July launch of the service.
In 2010, $466.7 million of funding was allocated in 2010 for a period of two years to launch a personally-controlled e-health record system for all Australians from 1 July.
Funding for the program was scheduled to run out this year, however the program has been given a $233.7 million boost for the next two years in the 2012-2013 Federal Budget.
-----

No more talking, we are ‘doing’ for rural health

8th May 2012
WHEN it comes to improving rural health services, it’s time for practical solutions.
The challenges are well known: shortages of health workers, older hospitals and health facilities and long distances to specialist centres, all have to be addressed so that rural Australians can get the health care they need, when and where they need it. 
We have to think smarter and work harder with an obvious starting point being how to increase the numbers of doctors, nurses and allied health professionals in the bush. 
One of the ways that we are making it more attractive for doctors to work in rural Australia is through significant bonus payments for doctors who choose to work in the most remote locations and retention payments to encourage others to stay in these areas. 
-----

UQ develops hi-tech tools to fight cancer

AN Australian team has used computational methods to gain insights into cancer biology that would not otherwise have been found.
The University of Queensland researchers are using computational systems biology to explore the networks of gene regulation.
Led by Mark Ragan from UQ's Institute for Molecular Bioscience, the team found using computers to untangle the intricacies of cancer biology could identify treatment targets that would not have otherwise been considered.
-----

Students create life-saving digital stethoscope

A team of university students have created a potentially game changing medical device using one smartphone and the Cloud
A digital stethoscope, which uses a smartphone and the Cloud, could save thousands of children’s lives in developing countries.
The stethoscope has been created by four university students from Victoria for the Imagine Cup, which challenges students around the world to develop unique products using technology.
The creators of the digital stethoscope, Team StethoCloud, include Hon Weng Chong, Andrew Lin, Kim Ramchen and Masha Salehi, and they are hoping the product can be readily used in developing countries.
“The idea behind this is that due to the rapid proliferation of mobile phone technology in developing countries, such as India and Africa, and the mobile phone being a readily accessible, we can then harness the availability of the technology [to help reduce childhood mortality],” Weng Chong tells Computerworld Australia.
-----

DoHA to get new financials software suite

Currently uses Excel spreadsheets to manage its $579 million annual budget and financial management requirements
The Department of Health and Ageing (DoHA) is moving to address weaknesses in its ability to meet financial management requirements through the adoption of a budget management and forecasting software suite.
The new commercial off the shelf software suite will help redress procedural inefficiencies, usability deficiencies, and provide increased flexibility and integration with reporting tools. The software will also promote greater use of the budgeting tool and assist in alignment with the Australian National Audit Office better practice recommendations.
According to DoHA documents, the department currently relies on Microsoft Excel to manage departmental and administered budgets and its internal allocation, monitoring and reporting.
-----

Holographic 3D video conferences now a reality

May 7, 2012 - 10:15AM
Skype and video iChat are great, but traditional video conferencing tools are so two-dimensional. Just imagine if you could talk to a friend or colleague in holographic 3D.
Well, you may soon be able to. Researchers at Queen's University in Canada have created a life-sized, 3D video conferencing pod that allows users to see the person they are talking to in 360-degree holographic-like clarity.
They call it the TeleHuman.
But before images of Princess Leia telling Obi-Wan Kenobi that he is her only hope start dancing in your head, know that the 3D holographic image only works if you have what looks like a giant cylindrical floor lamp made of acrylic that can display the life-sized 3D holographic image in your home or office.
-----

Journey to the centre of the brain

May 10, 2012
Close study ... "if we are ever to understand the brain in full, we must know how every neuron inside is wired up."
Researchers have a goal so ambitious it is almost unthinkable - learning how all 85 billion neurons in the human brain are wired up, writes Ian Sample.
There is a macabre brilliance to the machine in Jeff Lichtman's laboratory at Harvard University that is worthy of a Wallace and Gromit film. In one end goes brain. Out the other comes sliced brain, courtesy of an automated arm that wields a diamond knife. The slivers of tissue drop one after another on to a conveyor belt that zips along with the merry whirr of a cine projector.
Lichtman's machine is an automated tape-collecting lathe ultramicrotome (Atlum). It produces long strips of sticky tape with brain slices attached, all ready to be photographed through a powerful electron microscope. When these pictures are combined into 3D images, they reveal the inner wiring of the organ, a tangled mass of nervous spaghetti. The research by Lichtman and his co-workers has a goal in mind that is so ambitious it is almost unthinkable.
-----
Enjoy!
David.

AusHealthIT Poll Number 121 – Results – 14th May, 2012.

The question was:
Should NEHTA and The E-Health Group From DoHA Be Merged To Form A New E-Health Agency Under Standard Federal Government Controls?
For Sure
-  16 (45%)
Probably
-  6 (17%)
Maybe
-  5 (14%)
Definitely Not
 - 8 (22%)
Votes 35
Quite an interesting outcome with almost ½ the votes saying for sure and a good deal more supporting the idea - only 22% strongly against.
Again, many thanks to those that voted!
David.

Sunday, May 13, 2012

With The Senate Estimates Committee Reviewing DoHA and NEHTA Very Soon We Know What Some Questions Will Be About.

The following appeared yesterday:

Gravy train on the move

  • by: Sue Dunlevy and Karen Dearne
  • From: The Australian
  • May 12, 2012 12:00AM
PHARMACEUTICAL companies have been forced to curb their extravagant entertainment of doctors, but e-health is emerging as the latest gravy train in the health sector and this time it's the taxpayer footing the bill.
.....
Yet the biggest e-health gravy train is being run by the body in charge of setting up the new personally controlled e-health record, the National E-Health Transition Authority (NEHTA).
The e-health system will barely be operational from its July 1 start date, but the body in charge of the $760 million system is spending taxpayers' money on lavish seafood dinners, after-dinner speakers, flights and accommodation in connection with functions held in five-star hotels.
Critics are questioning the way NEHTA has spent its three-year, $218m budget after revelations that it has held 731 functions for stakeholders since January last year, while the e-health system is behind schedule.
NEHTA told a Senate estimates committee it had spent $871,000 on taxi fares in the past two financial years, $118,000 on business class international airfares and $2.1m in total on travel.
.....
"Depending on the duration of the function, food may be provided," she points out.
But Weekend Health has learned many of these functions were held in five-star hotels in Sydney, and often included a three-course dinner for hundreds of people in hotel dining rooms, and a comedian or motivational dinner speaker.
Opposition e-health spokesman Andrew Southcott claims the scheme has all the signs of being "pink batts on steroids".
"The fact they are spending money on these dinners when on July 1 no health provider will be able to use an e-health record is scandalous," he says.
Australian Medical Association president Steve Hambleton says the amount NEHTA has been spending on entertainment is "shocking", especially as it is still unclear whether it has done the job it was set up to do.
Health Minister Tanya Plibersek has been forced to play down expectations about the new scheme as NEHTA runs behind time in delivering the system.
All most patients will be able to do from July 1 is register interest in a personally controlled e-health record, because doctors, hospitals and health services won't have the software to run it.
NEHTA has refused to answer questions about the cost of the dinners and stakeholder meetings but event manager Forum Group Events says it would typically cost about $85 a head to run a two-day conference at a five-star hotel for more than 100 people. A three-course dinner with drinks would typically cost about $120 a head.
Weekend Health is aware of four such dinners held in the past 13 months.
.....
Disclosure: Karen Dearne attended a NEHTA-funded lunch in Canberra in 2010.
More revelations and details are found here.
I am told Budget Senate  Estimates hearings will be held from Monday, 21 May to Thursday, 24 May and Monday  28 May to Thursday, 31 May 2012.
Looking at the program it looks like the DoHA / NEHTA hearings will be in the second week. The current program is found here:
While admitting that all this seems vastly over the top at first glance I think the sensible thing to do it to wait to form judgement until after the Senate Estimates Hearings. I think you can be sure the questions are already being developed in the offices of the relevant Senators.
I have also to say that conversations I have had with people who know a good deal more than I do about the individual events do suggest there has been at the very least a level of largess and expenditure that might have been just a little excessive.  It is hard to know just why comedians and the like are necessary unless they bring specific domain expertise - which I doubt.
I am sure the Estimates hearings will make for interesting watching - they can all be watched on line via live streaming via this link.
I will let people know as soon as possible when the relevant session(s) are on.
David.