Quote Of The Year

Timeless Quotes - Sadly The Late Paul Shetler - "Its not Your Health Record it's a Government Record Of Your Health Information"

or

H. L. Mencken - "For every complex problem there is an answer that is clear, simple, and wrong."

Thursday, November 05, 2020

The Macro View – Health, Economics, and Politics and the Big Picture. What I Am Watching Here And Abroad.

November 05, 2020 Edition.

-----

In the US we are all wondering just where we are and what comes next – hopefully it will be clear by the weekend.

The UK has gone back into lockdown starting today their time until the end of the month. Its going to be too little, too last I suspect. I get the feeling the PM is doomed and that this will play out over the next month or so…

In OZ we are still leading a charmed life. I really hope it can last and the economic repair can happen. There are a lot of people hurting out there and I fear a miserable Christmas.

-----

Major Issues.

-----

https://www.smh.com.au/national/nsw/religious-discrimination-bill-will-create-an-unholy-mess-20201022-p567jx.html

Religious discrimination bill will create an unholy mess

By Alastair Lawrie

October 26, 2020 — 12.30am

One Nation’s Anti-Discrimination Amendment (Religious Freedoms and Equality) Bill 2020 gets one thing right — the lack of protection for religious belief is a genuine gap in NSW anti-discrimination law.

But when it comes to the detail, the bill not only goes the wrong way about introducing these much-needed protections, it represents a serious threat to the rights of all people in NSW.

The problem arises because of the prioritisation of religious beliefs over the rights of others, with privileges provided to schools, charities and even some commercial businesses to discriminate against others, including people of minority faiths or those of no faith.

To see what this will mean in practice, we can look to one of the many examples provided in the explanatory notes which One Nation State Leader Mark Latham has urged us to read to obtain a “full understanding of what the bill is trying to achieve”.

-----

https://www.smh.com.au/business/consumer-affairs/when-the-public-side-with-the-powerful-over-press-freedom-we-all-lose-20201025-p568bw.html

When the public side with the powerful over press freedom, we all lose

By Osman Faruqi

October 26, 2020 — 5.00am

Late last Thursday, on the eve of the AFL grand final public holiday, Victoria’s Department of Health and Human Services issued a statement likely to have a significant impact on how journalists report on the government’s handling of the state’s second wave of coronavirus.

DHHS announced that a public servant had been referred to the police for leaking a draft of a government document detailing the road map out of restrictions.

In September, the Herald Sun reported the draft, dismissed by premier Daniel Andrews at the time as having “no status”, even though it proved to be remarkably accurate.

In normal times, a decision by a government department to refer one of its own employees to the police for leaking to the media would spark a larger conversation about freedom of the press. But the timing of the news meant the story didn’t attract enormous attention.

When I tweeted about it I was surprised at the number of people who expressed support for the referral to police. Perhaps naively, I thought that the kind of people who follow me (they tend to be more left-leaning and generally supportive of the role journalism plays in society) would understand the consequences of a police investigation into a leak to journalists.

-----

https://www.afr.com/policy/economy/gatekeepers-should-have-picked-up-australia-post-asic-sooner-20201026-p568q6

Gatekeepers should have picked up Australia Post, ASIC sooner

A government corporation and a regulator are in trouble because systems of oversight did not work.

Helen Bird Contributor

Oct 27, 2020 – 12.00am

The best way to understand governance issues in any organisation is to follow the money. Two very different government organisations are in the spotlight this week for paying their staff questionable remuneration entitlements. The Australian Securities and Investments Commission for paying a $118,000 tax advice bill for its chairman and a $70,000 rental bill for its deputy chairman. Australia Post, for gifting Cartier watches worth a total of $19,950 to four executives.

Both organisations are the subject of government inquiries. ASIC chairman James Shipton has stood aside; his deputy, Daniel Crennan, QC, has resigned with immediate effect. Australia Post's CEO Christine Holgate has been forced to stand aside pending an inquiry into her organisation.

What both organisations have in common is their accountability to government. Both are subject to the Public Governance, Performance and Accountability Act 2013 (PGPA) . Additionally, the governance of Australia Post must align with Commonwealth government oversight rules.

The PGPA imposes private company director-like obligations on officials who work for accountable authorities.

-----

https://www.afr.com/companies/media-and-marketing/kevin-rudd-s-royal-commission-push-hits-a-nerve-20201022-p567lt

Kevin Rudd's royal commission push hits a nerve

Aaron Patrick Senior correspondent

Oct 27, 2020 – 9.35am

In Kevin Rudd's long and storied history of enemy making, he has never made a direct assault quite like this.

The former prime minister is petitioning the federal Parliament for a royal commission into the political influence of the Murdoch media empire, an organisation without a reputation for treating opponents gently.

Kevin07 has clearly hit a nerve. With a little bit of a publicity from the Nine papers and the ABC, the petition is closing in on 400,000 digital signatures, which dwarfs most of the hundreds of other random and self-interested pleas seeking parliamentary intervention.

Malcolm Turnbull, who encouraged the left-wing Guardian to open in Australia, has crossed the partisan aisle to sign. Turnbull said Murdoch had operated a monopoly in print since 1987, and praised Rudd for the idea.

-----

https://www.smh.com.au/politics/federal/audit-office-funding-slashed-renewing-calls-for-integrity-commission-20201026-p568q5.html

Audit office funding slashed, renewing calls for integrity commission

By Katina Curtis

October 26, 2020 — 9.58pm

The Commonwealth's default integrity watchdog has lost nearly a fifth of its funding since the Coalition came to power.

As the Law Council of Australia joins calls for a Commonwealth integrity commission to be established as soon as possible, a Parliamentary Library analysis of the Australian National Audit Office's budget since 2012-13 shows its total resourcing fell from $77.8 million to $63.6 million in 2012-13 dollars, a cut of more than 18 per cent in real terms.

Auditor-General Grant Hehir has said that budget constraints have already hindered the audit office's work and will continue to do so in the future unless it receives more funding.

The analysis, commissioned by Labor MP Julian Hill, also shows the office's annual resourcing has steadily trended down over that time while its expenses rose sharply in 2018-19.

-----

https://www.smh.com.au/politics/federal/early-release-of-superannuation-opened-up-a-frontier-for-financial-abuse-20201027-p568wx.html

Early release of superannuation 'opened up a frontier' for financial abuse

By Shane Wright and Katina Curtis

October 27, 2020 — 11.21am

The Tax Office has promised to review the early release of superannuation after revealing it did not have systems in place to prevent the scheme from being exploited by domestic abuse perpetrators.

Under questioning from the Labor Party, ATO commissioner Chris Jordan said it was "intolerable" if there were cases of financial abuse through the $34.4 billion in super released early as part of the Morrison government's stimulus package to protect the nation from the coronavirus recession.

People have been able to withdraw up to $10,000 in two separate transactions from their super. As of October 18, more than 4.5 million people have dipped into their retirement savings.

Last year, in public consultation about early access to super, several consumer organisations warned there was a risk that women could be pressured by their partners to take money out of their superannuation.

-----

https://www.afr.com/policy/economy/why-the-price-of-cheap-money-will-always-be-too-high-20201028-p56995

Why the price of cheap money will always be too high

The pandemic crisis will expose the problems created by the easy money answers to the financial crisis of a decade ago.

Warren Hogan Columnist

Oct 29, 2020 – 12.00am

Next Tuesday, the Reserve Bank of Australia is expected to reduce the cash rate to another record low. Monetary policy in most advanced economies is suffering from overreach and has been for much of the past decade.

Many of the problems economies face cannot be solved by easy money. They are structural, so can only be remediated through adjustments to economic arrangements, such as taxation, competition, industry and trade policy.

Over the past two decades there has been a loss of perspective about what monetary policy can and cannot achieve. It is a tool to impact on demand in the economy in the short term. It cannot impact on demand over the long run nor can it influence the supply side of the economy – at least, not in a positive manner.

One of the most worrying features of the world economy has been persistently weak productivity growth in many advanced economies. This apparent secular stagnation is characterised by a loss of economic dynamism, weak real wage growth and low consumer price inflation. Yet asset prices and debt levels are surging higher.

-----

https://www.smh.com.au/national/gravity-waves-epigenetics-win-top-australian-science-prize-20201028-p569fp.html

Gravitational waves, epigenetics win top Australian science prize

By Liam Mannix

October 28, 2020 — 7.00pm

When Professor Susan Scott was a physics student, the general thinking among scientists was discovering gravitational waves was next to impossible.

She disagreed.

Albert Einstein’s theory of general relativity imagines space and time as a combined entity that can be stretched and shaped like a sheet of elastic.

One consequence of that idea: if you drop something sufficiently heavy on the middle of the sheet, small ripples will spread to the edges. The fabric of reality will literally ripple – a gravitational wave.

“Einstein himself really thought there wasn’t a hope in hell of anyone detecting gravitational waves, given how small their amplitude was,” Professor Scott said.

-----

https://www.afr.com/politics/federal/there-is-a-fairer-and-open-way-to-appoint-the-best-high-court-judges-20201028-p569gy

There is a fairer and open way to appoint the best High Court judges

Establishing in Australia a UK-style independent judicial appointment commission would avoid the political circus around the US Supreme Court while creating a transparent, competitive and merit-based process.

Kim Rubenstein Contributor

Oct 29, 2020 – 1.44pm

Judicial appointments to each of the highest courts in the United States of America and Australia made for a momentous week both for court watchers and anyone understanding the singular reach of these supreme courts.

In America, the appointment of Justice Amy Coney Barrett happened in a rush when she was confirmed by the majority-held Republican Senate ahead of Tuesday’s Presidential elections. The judicial conservative replaces her mirror opposite Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg and will begin hearing cases when the court next sits in November.

In Australia, the process appeared more orderly. Justice Simon Steward replaces High Court Justice Geoffrey Nettle on his retirement on November 30, and Justice Jacqueline Gleeson begins her term when Justice Virginia Bell retires on February 28.

-----

https://www.smh.com.au/business/the-economy/rise-and-fall-how-the-inflation-dragon-has-been-slayed-20201029-p569up.html

Rise and fall: How the inflation dragon has been slayed

Ross Gittins

Economics Editor

October 30, 2020 — 12.00am

Treasury Secretary Dr Steven Kennedy observed this week that there’s been “a fundamental shift in the macro-economic underpinnings of the global and domestic economies, the cause of which is still not fully understood”. He’s right. And he’s the first of our top econocrats to say it. But he didn’t elaborate.

This week we got further evidence of that fundamental shift. The Australian Bureau of Statistics’ consumer price index for the September quarter showed an annual “headline” inflation rate of 0.7 per cent and an “underlying” (that is, more reliable) rate of 1.2 per cent.

This is exceptionally low and is clearly affected by the coronacession, as you’d expect. But there’s more going on than just a recession. Since 1993, our inflation target has been for annual inflation to average 2 to 3 per cent. For the six years before the virus, however, it averaged 1.6 per cent. And most other rich countries have also been undershooting their targets.

So, part of the “fundamental shift” in the factors underpinning the global economy is that inflation has gone away as a significant problem. But why? As Kennedy says, these things are “still not fully understood”. Some economists are advancing explanatory theories, which the other economists are debating.

-----

https://www.afr.com/politics/federal/morrison-shows-a-trumpian-disregard-for-transparency-20201030-p56a0a

PM shows a Trumpian disregard for transparency

Government outrage at the behaviour of big institutions seems to be driven by whose side they are perceived to be on.

Laura Tingle Columnist

Oct 30, 2020 – 4.50pm

Pause for a moment and let’s take ourselves back to November 2017, when the then Turnbull government was dragged kicking and screaming to set up a banking royal commission.

The then treasurer, Scott Morrison, had been one of the most ardent resisters of a royal commission, describing it as “a stunt”, “hot air” and “nothing more than crass populism seeking to undermine confidence in the banking and financial system, which is key to jobs and growth in this country".

Even when the government finally announced the royal commission, he described it as a “regrettable but necessary action”.

"Politics is doing damage to our banking and financial system, and we are taking control as a government to protect the strength of our banking system through a properly constituted inquiry on these terms of reference, rather than the alternatives present in other commission of inquiry proposals,” Morrison said at the time.

-----

https://www.smh.com.au/politics/federal/trump-and-china-force-australia-to-secure-its-defence-closer-to-home-20201030-p56a8h.html

Trump and China force Australia to secure its defence closer to home

Peter Hartcher

Political and international editor for The Sydney Morning Herald and The Age

October 30, 2020 — 7.16pm

When Australia entrusted its national survival to the United States decades ago, it wasn't counting on Donald Trump. Whoever wins the US presidential election next week, the US alliance remains Australia's strategic Plan A. But the election of the self-described "very stable genius" four years ago has pointed up the danger inherent in betting the nation's existence on any one country.

At the same time, Xi Jinping's China presents Australia with the stark reality that it confronts a big, hostile power that respects no country's sovereignty but its own.

Together, these facts have pushed Australia to start work on a Plan B. What's the plan? To bring together as many other countries as possible to "balance" against China's power.

Or, as ANU professor emeritus Hugh White put it, "we no longer repose our trust in America alone, and if America fails us then we will look not to ourselves but to our Asian neighbours".

The Defence Minister, Linda Reynolds, prefers to call Australia's new strategy "an enhanced Plan A". Australia has nourished relationships with a wide range of Asia Pacific countries for decades, she points out, so that's not new. But "we are strengthening them in new ways".

-----

https://www.smh.com.au/politics/queensland/labor-claims-victory-to-win-third-term-in-queensland-20201031-p56aek.html

Labor claims victory to win third term in Queensland

By Cameron Atfield

October 31, 2020 — 11.38pm

Queensland Premier Annastacia Palaszczuk has won her third state election for Labor in a stunning endorsement of her tough border policy after an election campaign dominated by the state’s response to the COVID crisis.

But it was not all good news for the Labor Party, with the Greens claiming a significant scalp in the shape of former deputy premier and treasurer Jackie Trad, who lost her South Brisbane seat to Amy MacMahon.

A beaming Premier took to the stage at the Inala Blue Fin Fishing Club in Brisbane's west at 10.17pm to claim victory, which gives Labor Queensland its first four-year fixed term in power.

"It has not been an easy year for many, many people," she said.

-----

https://www.smh.com.au/business/markets/american-dream-or-nightmare-an-investor-s-field-guide-for-next-week-s-us-election-20201029-p569xe.html

American dream or nightmare?: An investor's field guide for next week's US election

By Alex Druce

October 31, 2020 — 12.12am

Investors have already endured one of the most dramatic years on record, but the defining moment for markets in 2020 could still be to come: polling day in next week’s US Presidential election between Donald Trump and Joe Biden.

Nerves are already on edge with coronavirus case numbers rising, yet with record numbers of mail-in votes, and the size and timing of the next US stimulus package still unknown, it seems the only certainty is that the impact of the result will be felt far beyond America’s shores.

Having mostly recovered from the depths of the coronavirus-induced rout in March, the path forward for share prices both in Australia and abroad will be sculpted not only by who wins the Oval Office on November 3 but the colour of the Senate.

Investors appear to have already priced in a Biden win, with many also anticipating a blue wave sweep of the upper house and the added certainty that would bring. But as four years ago showed, all scenarios are still on the table. A Trump victory is still very much possible, so too is the nightmare scenario for investors of a drawn out, contested result.

-----

Coronavirus And Impacts.

-----

https://www.smh.com.au/world/europe/un-head-calls-covid-the-greatest-crisis-of-our-age-as-spain-enters-state-of-emergency-20201026-p568i1.html

UN head calls COVID the 'greatest crisis of our age' as Spain enters state of emergency

By Belén Carreño

October 26, 2020 — 6.53am

Madrid: Spanish Prime Minister Pedro Sanchez has announced a new state of emergency in an effort to curb soaring coronavirus infections as the head of the United Nations declared that “the COVID-19 pandemic is the greatest crisis of our age”.

France also registered a record 52,010 new confirmed coronavirus cases over the past 24 hours, following a record 45,422 on Saturday, the health ministry said on Sunday, as the coronavirus continues to spread throughout Europe.

Spain will impose measures including nighttime curfews and limits on the number of people allowed to meet in a bid to contain a surging second wave of coronavirus infections.

UN Secretary-General Antonio Guterres opened an online session of the World Health Summit with a call for worldwide solidarity in the global crisis and demanded that developed countries support health systems in countries that are short of resources.

The coronavirus pandemic is the overarching theme of the summit, which originally had been scheduled for Berlin. Several of the leaders and experts who spoke at the opening stressed the need to cooperate across borders.

-----

https://www.smh.com.au/world/north-america/white-house-says-it-won-t-control-the-pandemic-as-more-senior-staffers-test-positive-20201026-p568kg.html

White House says it won't 'control the pandemic' as more senior staffers test positive

By Farrah Tomazin

October 26, 2020 — 10.29am

The White House has conceded it is “not going to control the pandemic” as it faces another staff outbreak nine days from the US election.

Three weeks after President Donald Trump and members of his inner circle contracted coronavirus, five staffers working for Vice-President Mike Pence – including his chief of staff – have also been diagnosed with COVID-19.

Pence and his wife Karen say they have tested negative, and the Vice-President will keep campaigning across the US for the final stretch of the race rather than self isolate.

But as cases continue to soar in most states, White House chief of staff Mark Meadows revealed today that the Trump administration was not aiming to control the virus, and instead was focusing its efforts on the development of a vaccine to stop the spread.

-----

https://www.afr.com/politics/federal/morrison-credits-the-people-of-victoria-not-daniel-andrews-20201026-p568q8

Morrison credits the people of Victoria – not Daniel Andrews

Phillip Coorey Political editor

Oct 26, 2020 – 6.34pm

Senior Labor figures say the business community has all but given up on the Andrews government and has been liaising increasingly with federal MPs in a bid to communicate.

As Victorian Premier Daniel Andrews announced the lifting of months of severe stage four restrictions on Monday, federal Labor figures said business leaders had been contacting them throughout the lockdown, complaining of being virtually ignored.

As recently as last week, at the same time Mr Andrews said he had not bothered to read a letter from seven of the nation's most senior CEOs urging him to reopen his state in a COVID-safe manner, Victorian Treasurer Tim Pallas cancelled a scheduled meeting with the Business Council of Australia, the first such hearing he had granted since August.

Sources inside both federal Labor and the corporate community said the virtually non-existent relationship between the business sector and state Labor that existed before the crisis was now a poisonous one.

After a visceral reaction from the business community to his Sunday decision to pause the lifting of restrictions, Mr Andrews on Monday said cafes, pubs and retail would reopen on Wednesday and the rest of the economy would start to open on November 8.

-----

https://www.smh.com.au/politics/nsw/fears-of-a-second-covid-wave-and-another-lockdown-on-nsw-voters-minds-20201026-p568pl.html

Fears of a second COVID wave and another lockdown on NSW voters' minds

By Alexandra Smith

October 26, 2020 — 6.03pm

Fears of a second wave of COVID-19 in NSW and being forced back into lockdown are top of mind for three out of five voters in the state, with most also worried about a drawn-out recession.

An exclusive Ipsos poll for The Sydney Morning Herald and Nine News reveals 63 per cent of voters are concerned that NSW could follow Victoria and be hit with a high number of COVID-19 cases.

NSW had one new locally acquired case and three cases in hotel quarantine on Monday while Victoria recorded its first day in four months of no new cases, allowing it to ease restrictions.

NSW Health confirmed the locally acquired case in Sydney is a household contact of a positive test linked with the Oran Park cluster, which has been connected with 23 coronavirus cases.

-----

https://www.afr.com/world/europe/europe-s-second-wave-brushes-past-lockdown-lite-20201028-p5697d

Europe's second wave brushes past 'lockdown lite'

Hans van Leeuwen Europe correspondent

Oct 28, 2020 – 4.35am

London | Europe's second wave of the COVID-19 pandemic has swept past the light-touch restrictions put in place in most parts of the Continent, sparking warnings that tougher, economy-sapping measures could follow.

The seemingly unstoppable resurgence comes as a new study from Imperial College in London suggests that COVID antibodies may last only a few months in the human system, throwing into doubt the prospect of herd immunity and workable vaccines.

Germany, which fended off the first wave and has so far put in place only limited restrictions this time, could hit 20,000 new cases a day by the week's end, Economy Minister Peter Altmaier warned late on Tuesday (AEDT).

"We are dealing with exponential growth," he said, ahead of a COAG-style meeting between Chancellor Angela Merkel and the 16 state premiers on Wednesday to discuss further lockdown measures such as a period of business closures.

In France, Interior Minister Gerald Darmanin said the French people would have to "prepare for difficult decisions", on a day when the country clocked 33,417 new cases and reached almost 50 per cent capacity in its intensive care wards.

-----

https://www.afr.com/life-and-luxury/health-and-wellness/severe-covid-19-infection-appears-to-give-better-protection-study-20201027-p568y3

Severe COVID-19 infection appears to give better protection: study

Jill Margo Health editor

Oct 27, 2020 – 11.34am

People who experience severe COVID-19 disease may have a small advantage over those who had it mildly, according to new research.

A study in the journal Nature Microbiology says they may be protected against reinfection for longer periods than those with milder symptoms.

Antibody responses to the virus can be detected in most infected people 10 to 15 days after the onset of COVID-19 symptoms.

However, it is not known how long antibody responses will be maintained or whether they will provide protection from reinfection.

By using sequential blood samples collected up to 94 days after the first symptoms appeared, the authors found the immune response to the virus waned in the three months following infection and was dependent on the severity of the disease.

-----

https://www.smh.com.au/politics/federal/cashed-up-australians-squirrel-away-100-billion-20201030-p56a4m.html

Cashed-up Australians squirrel away $100 billion

By Shane Wright

October 30, 2020 — 10.10pm

Cashed-up Australians have squirrelled away $100 billion in their bank accounts since the start of the coronavirus recession as they remain fearful the pandemic will weigh on the economy and their own finances well into the future.

Data from the Australian Prudential Regulation Authority on Friday showed another surge in bank deposits held by households with the nation's lenders, jumping by $16.5 billion through September.

The authority noted the increase was likely due to JobKeeper payments and tax refunds flowing into accounts in the month. Deposits have also been boosted by increased government payments, mortgage repayment deferrals and the withdrawal of $34.5 billion from superannuation accounts.

Since the start of the pandemic in February, $100 billion has been put away by households waiting for a change in the economy.

-----

Climate Change

-----

No articles in this section.

-----

Royal Commissions And The Like.

-----

https://www.theaustralian.com.au/breaking-news/bushfire-royal-commission-recommends-national-emergency-powers/news-story/27c0410c670a096a648eab6b9cbd27e3

Bushfire Royal Commission recommends national emergency powers

Jade Gailberger

The federal government should have the power to declare a state of national emergency, according to a final report handed down by the royal commission into last summer’s catastrophic bushfires.

The proposed change is among 80 recommendations made public on Friday after the report was tabled in parliament.

The Black Summer blazes torched 10 million hectares, destroyed more than 3,000 homes and killed 33 people.

The thick smoke that blanketed parts of Australia for weeks on end contributed to hundreds more deaths, the inquiry found.

-----

https://www.theaustralian.com.au/nation/closing-the-gap-35bn-funding-short-on-checks/news-story/34e88a965065808aa527eeb557cb9844

Closing the gap: $35bn funding short on checks

Paige Taylor

The nation's chief economic ­adviser has called for a complete overhaul of billions of dollars in federal ­spending on indigenous support each year, in a major ­report that warns the government has little evidence that current programs are effective.

In an excoriating verdict on the nation’s indigenous programs, the Productivity Commission has found that, despite massive spending to address disadvantage, the government’s evidence of what works — and why — is “thin’’.

It says many programs are ­developed without adequate consultation with Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander communities and efforts to find out if they have been effective are “ad hoc’’ or afterthoughts.

The report, to be released on Friday, comes after a decade of failures under the old Closing the Gap agreement.

-----

https://www.theaustralian.com.au/nation/defence/more-disasters-inevitable-prepare-now/news-story/f36a5332078ac63e79a8662ce222d31e

More disasters inevitable: prepare now

Olivia Caisley

Climate change was a key factor behind the Black Summer fires and the nation must bolster its disaster-response mechanisms as extreme weather becomes more frequent and severe, the bushfire royal commission has concluded.

And there are no “authoritative agreed set of climate change ­scenarios for the nation”, the commission’s final report warned.

And while Australia has a “naturally variable climate”, the inquiry led by former Chief of Air Force Mark Binskin said “weather has ­already become more frequent and intense because of climate change; further global warming over the next 20 to 30 years is inevitable”.

The Royal Commission into ­National Natural Disaster Arrangements was commissioned by the Morrison government in February in the wake of fires that killed 33 people and caused billions of dollars in damage.

-----

National Budget Issues.

-----

https://www.smh.com.au/politics/federal/millions-face-a-pay-cut-when-lamington-offset-ends-despite-tax-cuts-20201027-p5691j.html

Millions face a pay cut when 'lamington' offset ends, despite tax cuts

By Shane Wright

October 28, 2020 — 5.00am

Millions of low and middle income Australians face being $1080 a year worse off unless the Morrison government revisits its just-completed overhaul of the personal tax system.

The end of the low and middle income tax offset for the 2021-22 financial year means people earning between $48,000 and $90,000 will suffer a $20 a week hit to their take-home income with up to 10 million taxpayers suffering.

Exclusive modelling for The Age and The Sydney Morning Herald by the Bankwest Curtin Economics Centre reveals the pressure both the government and Labor will face to promise more tax relief to voters ahead of the next election.

As part of its response to the coronavirus recession, the government announced in the budget it would bring forward tax cuts previously planned to start in mid-2022, which will benefit people earning more than $90,000. Those tax cuts are due to start flowing into people's paypackets within weeks.

-----

https://www.smh.com.au/politics/federal/recession-likely-over-says-rba-but-recovery-looks-rocky-20201027-p5693i.html

Recession likely over, says RBA, but recovery looks rocky

By Shane Wright

October 27, 2020 — 6.30pm

The Australian economy has emerged from its first recession in 30 years, the Reserve Bank believes but is warning the recovery will be marred by growing business failures and cash-strapped households struggling to pay off their mortgages.

Deputy governor Guy Debelle on Tuesday told a Senate estimates hearing that it appeared the Australian economy grew through the September quarter.

The economy contracted through the first six months of the year with the June quarter posting the largest three month slowdown since the end of World War Two. It was the first time since 1990-91 that the economy had contracted for two consecutive quarters.

But Dr Debelle said the economy probably expanded over the previous three months even taking into account the shutdown of Victoria through all of the period.

"At the moment our best guess is it looks like the economy probably recorded positive growth rather than negative," he said.

-----

https://www.smh.com.au/business/the-economy/privatisation-crusade-has-long-been-core-business-for-tribal-libs-20201027-p568xg.html

Privatisation crusade has long been core business for tribal Libs

Ross Gittins

Economics Editor

October 28, 2020 — 12.00am

Critics of this year’s strange budget, which claims to be “all about jobs” but is really about helping some people and not helping others, accuse Scott Morrison and his faithful Treasurer of being “ideological”. That’s not a sensible criticism.

To accuse someone you disagree with of being “ideological” is dishonest and hypocritical. It misuses the word, turning it into a meaningless term of abuse. It implies that you’re being ideological, but I’m not.

To be ideological is to hold to a system of beliefs about how the world works and how it should work. So every adult who hasn’t wasted too much of their life watching reality television rather than thinking has an ideology — some better thought through than others.

When I accuse you of being “ideological”, what I’m really saying is that your ideology differs from my ideology and I think yours is wrong.

But I object to the term also because it’s an attempt to intellectualise and dignify a motivation far less noble: our deeply evolutionary instinct to form ourselves into tribes. My side, your side. Us and them. Good guys versus bad guys.

-----

https://www.theaustralian.com.au/business/economics/australia-ends-brief-flirtation-with-deflation/news-story/0e4adbed03981e5682fb9c331c2aa353

Australia ends brief flirtation with deflation

Patrick Commins

Consumer prices lifted by 1.6 per cent over the three months to September, as the end of free childcare and a bounce in petrol prices ended Australia’s brief flirtation with deflation.

Annual inflation came in at 0.7 per cent, seasonally adjusted figures from the Australian Bureau of Statistics showed, after falling by 0.3 per cent over the year to June – which was only the third time consumer price growth has been negative going back to 1949.

Over the June quarter, a 95 per cent fall in childcare costs, falling rents and plunging petrol prices through the three months drove the steepest fall in the consumer price basket on record at 1.9 per cent.

The Morrison government brought an end to its temporary childcare support on July 13, and this comprised 0.9 percentage points of the 1.6 per cent lift in CPI in the September quarter, the ABS said.

Massive spending on products to set up home offices and the like as more Australians worked out of the office drove an incredible 12 per cent jump in prices for furnishings, household equipment and services, the data showed.

-----

https://www.smh.com.au/politics/federal/don-t-put-up-the-end-of-recession-balloons-just-yet-20201028-p569ch.html

Don't put up the end of recession balloons just yet

By Shane Wright

October 28, 2020 — 3.38pm

The economy may again be growing but it's way too early to hold a "I survived the COVID recession" party.

Reserve Bank deputy governor Guy Debelle this week grabbed plenty of attention when he remarked that it appeared the economy had grown through the September quarter.

The Reserve Bank of Australia has indicated the economy will grow in September, possibly ending the recession.

After the 0.3 per cent contraction of GDP in the March quarter, and the record-breaking 7 per cent contraction in the June quarter, a return to growth is a positive development.

For those who live or die on the definition of a recession as two quarters of negative growth, it appeared the RBA's number two was readying the drinks for his own end-of-recession celebration.

-----

https://www.afr.com/policy/economy/rba-s-recession-fight-not-over-yet-20201029-p569jx

RBA's recession fight not over yet

John Kehoe Senior writer

Oct 29, 2020 – 4.06pm

The recession might have technically ended by one crude measure, but for the Reserve Bank of Australia its recession-fighting toolkit is about to shift into uncharted territory.

When RBA deputy governor Guy Debelle told a Senate committee on Tuesday that "it looks like the September quarter for the country probably recorded positive growth rather than slightly negative", the recession was declared over by some commentators.

But dig deeper into the numbers and you will soon realise the economy is still in a deep rut, even if it is beginning to recover from the ravages of COVID-19 and lockdowns.

Economic output shrank a massive 7 per cent in the June quarter. Mathematically, it's not difficult to recover to a positive growth number from that low ebb and limp out of a technical recession.

Even if the national economy managed to eke out slightly positive growth in the three months to September 30 during the second Victoria lockdown, economic output is still likely to be more than 6 per cent below its pre-COVID-19 levels.

-----

https://www.theaustralian.com.au/business/economics/home-borrowing-jumps-most-in-two-years-rba-data-shows/news-story/faffa992c9f2f6f1c281e804905d6def

Home borrowing jumps most in two years, RBA data shows

Patrick Commins

Home lending in September grew at its fastest monthly pace in over two years, as falling rates and a resilient housing market helped keep credit flowing despite the COVID-19 recession’s heavy toll on jobs and livelihoods.

The total stock of housing loans lifted by 0.4 per cent last month, from 0.3 per cent in August, bringing the annual pace to 3.3 per cent from 3.2 per cent, new figures from the Reserve Bank of Australia showed.

While Australians are happy to snap up the cheapest loans in history to buy a home in which to live, businesses remain far less confident as the economy charts an uncertain path out of the deepest downturn since the 1930s.

The stock of outstanding business credit dropped by a further 0.3 per cent in September, the fifth consecutive month of declines, slowing the annual growth rate to 2 per cent from 2.9 per cent in August.

Owner-occupiers once again accounted for the bulk of increased home borrowing, recording gains of 0.5 per cent in September and by 5.4 per cent versus the same period a year earlier, according to the seasonally adjusted data.

-----

https://www.afr.com/policy/economy/economists-investors-fear-rbas-cheap-money-wave-20201029-p569m3

RBA's rate cut to 'hurt recovery', savers

Matthew Cranston and Jonathan Shapiro

Updated Oct 31, 2020 – 12.16am, first published at Oct 30, 2020 – 6.04pm

Former Reserve Bank board member Warwick McKibbin has warned that rate cuts and quantitative easing by the RBA this Melbourne Cup day would undermine the economic recovery and further squeeze savers.

The RBA is expected to cut the cash rate from 0.25 per cent to 0.10 percent on Tuesday and announce as much as $163 billion in new bond purchases designed to reduce borrowing rates and stimulate the economy.

The big four banks' average conditional savings rate on deposits is now just 0.66 per cent according to RateCity, lower than the latest inflation reading of 0.7 per cent, indicating negative real interest rates or a situation where depositors are now virtually paying the bank to hold their money.

This month alone 50 banks have cut their savings rates.

-----

https://www.theaustralian.com.au/business/economics/taking-stock-of-meaningless-valuations-as-zero-rates-inflate-assets/news-story/6b0dcd9670b4f69e6cffa1b8a88acc24

Taking stock of meaningless valuations as zero rates inflate assets

Alan Kohler

This week’s CPI report for the September quarter must have been very dispiriting for the honest toilers at the Reserve Bank.

They have been cutting interest rates since November 2011 and this year embarked on one of the world’s biggest quantitative easing programs, yet underlying inflation is stuck at 1.2 per cent, half what they want. Next week rates will be cut again, along with making their quantitative easing the world’s largest — a final, futile, throw of the dice.

They might be telling each other it’s just the coronavirus, that it’ll be right when there’s a vaccine, but in their hearts, they must know it’s not only that: in the past five years, trimmed mean underlying inflation has averaged 0.4 per cent per quarter; in the five years before that, 0.6 per cent; and in the five years before that 0.8 per cent. It has been a long, inexorable decline.

Of course, this year’s sharp recession and unemployment hasn’t helped, even though aggregate income has increased because of government transfers and has been saved, not spent. Next Tuesday governor Philip Lowe will be forced to announce something he said he wouldn’t do: take the official cash rate below 0.25 per cent, which he said was equivalent to zero in Australia.

But it will be little more than symbolic. The market cash rate is already near enough to 0.1 per cent because of the liquidity the RBA has been flooding the system with, deliberately using cash as the rate cut you have before you have a rate cut.

-----

Health Issues.

-----

https://www.theaustralian.com.au/life/returning-to-a-healthy-weight-is-a-bridge-to-far-for-overweight-aussie-men/news-story/6ee225de34d1aed5c85255ff69ae9cc4

Returning to a healthy weight is a bridge too far for overweight Aussie men

Stephen Lunn

Once Australian men are fat, they rarely return to a healthy weight, a government study shows.

And the older we get, the fatter we get, the Australian Institute of Family Studies published on Thursday reveals.

Twenty per cent of 10-14 year old boys are overweight or obese, but by the time men reach 25-34, it is 60 per cent. More than 70 per cent of 35-57 year olds are too heavy.

The AIFS longitudinal study of more than 16,000 Australian males, Ten to Men, found about nine in 10 men aged 35-57 who were overweight or obese in 2013 remained so two years later.

-----

International Issues.

-----

https://www.afr.com/world/north-america/tense-days-ahead-as-trump-blitz-narrows-gaps-in-battleground-states-20201025-p568co

Tense days ahead as Trump blitz narrows gaps in battleground states

Jacob Greber United States correspondent

Updated Oct 25, 2020 – 4.58pm, first published at 2.26pm

Washington | Donald Trump is riding a bump in support across battleground states as he accelerates a campaign blitz reminiscent of 2016, when he shattered experts' conviction that he could not close the gap to his Democratic rival in time.

In a campaign blitzkrieg that mirrors his winning strategy from four years ago, Mr Trump did three rallies alone on Saturday (Sunday AEDT). Campaign sources say this is likely to set the pace right up until election day, with up to four rallies a day possible.

The frenetic schedule, which began with Mr Trump's recovery from his bout of COVID-19 ten days ago, has helped him make modest but material inroads into Joe Biden's lead.

Even though Mr Trump continues to trail Mr Biden nationally by more than 8 percentage points – 5 points more than where Hillary Clinton was on election eve in 2016 – the race in several key swing states has narrowed.

As of late on Saturday (Sunday AEDT), Mr Trump was 3.8 points behind Mr Biden in a RealClearPolitics average of polls across Florida, Pennsylvania, Michigan, Wisconsin, North Carolina and Arizona. The pollsters put the President at 45.5 per cent support versus the former vice-president's 49.3 per cent.

-----

https://www.smh.com.au/world/north-america/australia-will-benefit-if-american-craziness-subsides-20201022-p567ly.html

Australia will benefit if American craziness subsides

By Michael Fullilove

October 26, 2020 — 12.01am

In most US presidential election years – say, for the Clinton-Bush race in 1992, or Bush-Gore in 2000, or Obama-Romney in 2012 – a respectable debate can be had as to which candidate tracks more closely with Australia’s interests. 2020 is not such a year.

Would Donald Trump’s re-election favour Australia’s interests? To ask the question is to answer it. Making the argument for Trump may give its proponents a transgressive thrill, but it is not a serious proposition – at least for those of us who wish the United States well.

Australia’s interests are served when the United States is well-governed, cohesive, attractive to the world, and strong enough to deter bad behaviour by adversaries. Under Donald Trump’s presidency, the United States is poorly governed, divided, unappealing to the world, and weak – which leaves all of us vulnerable to malign actors.

On foreign policy, Trump’s actions run counter to our instincts. Australians are alliance believers; Trump thinks allies are scroungers. Australians are inclined towards internationalism; Trump is sympathetic to isolationism. Australia is a trading nation; Trump withdrew from the Trans-Pacific Partnership and attacked the World Trade Organisation. Australia is an old democracy and a free society; Trump swoons over strongmen like Vladimir Putin and – for much of his presidency – Xi Jinping.

-----

https://www.theaustralian.com.au/world/us-2020-race-trump-has-given-up-on-controlling-coronavirus-biden/news-story/c6ff8b730ca10d6c26f80a75db6c16e3

US 2020 race: Trump has given up on controlling coronavirus: Biden

Cameron Stewart

Joe Biden has accused Donald Trump of surrendering to the coronavirus after the president’s chief of staff admitted that the US is ‘not going to control the pandemic.’

The stark admission by Mark Meadows came despite Mr Trump telling his supporters the US is ‘rounding the turn’ on the virus even as infections have hit record new highs.

“We’re not going to control the pandemic … because it’s a contagious virus,” Mr Meadows said. “What we need to do is make sure we have the proper mitigation factors to make sure people don’t die.’

Mr Trump’s Democrat opponent, Mr Biden hit out at the comments, saying it showed the Trump administration had given up on protecting Americans.

-----

https://www.smh.com.au/world/north-america/sweet-moment-for-republicans-amy-coney-barrett-confirmed-as-supreme-court-judge-20201027-p568wg.html

Sweet moment for Republicans: Amy Coney Barrett confirmed as Supreme Court judge

By Matthew Knott

October 27, 2020 — 11.21am

Washington: When Ruth Bader Ginsberg died in mid-September, you could feel the tectonic plates of American politics shifting. Republicans announced almost immediately that they would move to fill the progressive icon's Supreme Court seat as soon as possible, setting up a highly-charged fight just weeks out from election day. Here was an issue, conservatives thought, that would fire up their base and shift the national conversation away from the coronavirus pandemic.

On Tuesday (AEDT) the nomination process came to end when the Senate voted to confirm Amy Coney Barrett in a 52-48 vote. Never before in US history has a Supreme Court justice been appointed so close to election day.

It's a sweet moment for Republicans, locking in a 6-3 conservative majority on the nation's most powerful court. President Donald Trump has now appointed three justices to the court in four years - more than Barack Obama, George W Bush or Bill Clinton appointed during their two-term presidencies.

Aged just 48, Barrett will likely sit on the bench for decades to come. And while some justices go "rogue" after being appointed, Republicans feel confident that Barrett will be a solid conservative vote on issues such as abortion and gun rights.

"This is the most openly pro-life judicial nominee to the Supreme Court in my lifetime," Republican Senator Josh Hawley said as the final confirmation vote approached. "This is an individual who has been open in her criticism of that illegitimate decision: Roe vs Wade."

-----

https://www.smh.com.au/world/north-america/trump-goes-with-his-gut-even-if-the-world-beyond-the-us-goes-belly-up-20201026-p568kv.html

Trump goes with his gut, even if the world beyond the US goes belly-up

Peter Hartcher

Political and international editor for The Sydney Morning Herald and The Age

October 27, 2020 — 12.00am

When Donald Trump hired John Bolton in 2018, he said that some people thought his new national security adviser was a "bad cop". He was invoking the idea that they could deploy the good cop-bad cop routine in managing other countries.

Then Trump delivered the punchline: "The trouble is, we've got two bad cops."

Bolton didn't reject the description. His hardline policy views are even more notorious than his exuberant moustache. But by the time he left the White House a year and a half later, he had a firm view of the essential difference between the "two bad cops".

"I had a world view," Bolton tells me. "And he didn't. He doesn't think in philosophical terms, or in terms of grand strategy, or in terms of policy as we conventionally understand it. That makes him different from all other presidents," says Bolton, who has worked for five now, all Republicans.

-----

https://www.smh.com.au/world/asia/in-the-us-election-s-shadow-chinese-leaders-try-to-define-next-decade-20201026-p568po.html

In the US election's shadow, Chinese leaders try to define next decade

By Eryk Bagshaw

October 26, 2020 — 5.37pm

The Chinese Communist Party's top decision makers are expected to formalise Beijing's priorities for the next five years in a series of closed-door meetings that will establish protections for the local economy, expand social welfare and further concentrate power in the hands of President Xi Jinping.

The closely guarded plenum between 205 powerbrokers in the party's Central Committee is taking place in the shadow of the US election but its ramifications will extend beyond the term of the next US President. The Party will finalise its 14th Five-Year Plan (2021-2025), and its "2035 vision" during the discussions this week.

It is the third major policy push from Xi in as many weeks after two key celebrations, the 40th anniversary of the city of Shenzhen and 70th anniversary of the Korean War were used by the party to ramp up its pursuit of socialist modernisation, stir nationalist sentiment and fend off foreign threats.

The 205 members of the Central Committee and 171 alternate members are selected from more than 2300 members of the Party Congress. The Central Committee elects the seven highest ranking members of the party to the Politburo Standing Committee and the General Secretary, also known as the President, making it the largest influential decision making body in China.

-----

https://www.afr.com/policy/economy/isolating-the-contagion-has-china-leading-america-again-20201027-p568wc

Isolating the contagion has China leading America again

China's fight COVID-19-first strategy has it on track for a sustained recovery. Donald Trump's economy-first policy has the US headed for a double-dip recession.

Stephen Roach Contributor

Oct 27, 2020 – 12.40pm

Just as China led the world in economic recovery in the aftermath of the global financial crisis of 2008, it is playing a similar role today.

Its post-COVID-19 rebound is gathering momentum amid a developed world that remains on shaky ground.

Unfortunately, this is a bitter pill for many to swallow – especially in the United States, where demonisation of China has reached epic proportions.

The two crises are, of course, different. Wall Street was ground zero for the 2008 crisis, while the COVID-19 pandemic was spawned in the wet markets of Wuhan.

-----

https://www.afr.com/world/asia/china-s-covid-triumphalism-could-be-premature-20201027-p568wl

China’s virus triumphalism could be premature

Leader cults rarely end well anywhere – and there is little reason to believe that China under Xi Jinping will ultimately be any different.

Gideon Rachman Columnist

Oct 27, 2020 – 9.32am

In 2009, Martin Jacques, a British author, published a bestselling book, When China Rules the World. Mr Jacques is now running a victory lap. He recently proclaimed that “we will remember 2020 as the moment of the Great Transition. The year when China replaced the US as the world’s leading power.”

Believers in a “great transition” see COVID-19 as the handmaiden of history. The pandemic started in China. But the Chinese government has done a much better job of containing the disease than the US.

According to Johns Hopkins University, the total number of US deaths from COVID-19 stood at over 223,000 at the end of last week compared with 4379 in China. With the disease contained, the Chinese economy is rebounding and looks set to grow 2 per cent this year, making it the only G20 economy to expand. The US economy is likely to shrink by 3 to 5 per cent and the major European economies are in trouble.

-----

https://www.afr.com/world/north-america/us-global-role-at-stake-in-next-week-s-election-20201028-p5699a

US global role at stake in next week's election

Constructive and competent leadership by a democratic US is needed more than ever, given the rising power of an increasingly autocratic China, the success of charismatic autocrats elsewhere and the great global challenges of our age. Trump cannot lead such a US.

Martin Wolf Columnist

Oct 28, 2020 – 9.26am

This US election is the most important since 1932, when Franklin Delano Roosevelt became president in the depths of the Depression. With much trial and error, FDR saved democracy, at home and abroad.

The re-election of Donald Trump would undo much, if not all, of that legacy. Yet his defeat would not end the danger. If that is to happen, American politics has to be transformed.

This election is so important, because the US plays a unique role in the world. It has long been the paramount model of a functioning liberal democracy, leader of the countries that share these values and an essential player in resolving any big global challenge.

The re-election of Trump would signify a rejection of all three roles by the American people. No other country or group of countries is able to take its place. The world would be transformed — and not at all for the better.

-----

https://www.afr.com/world/north-america/narrowing-battleground-race-stokes-fear-of-disputed-election-20201028-p5697q

Narrowing battleground race stokes fear of disputed election

It's happening again. Donald Trump has captured that most sought-after commodity in the dying days of any election: momentum.

Jacob Greber United States correspondent

Oct 28, 2020 – 12.39pm

Washington | It's happening again. Donald Trump is behind, but he's closing the gap – this time to Joe Biden and not to Hillary Clinton.

While Biden's chances of winning next week are still considerably greater than Trump's, the President has captured that most sought-after commodity in the dying days of any election: momentum.

He's generated it at the last possible moment, with a week to go, and mostly in Pennsylvania. It's probably still too late. In the meantime, however, all confident assertions of a Biden win should be tempered with a healthy dose of humility.

The momentum shift has taken place over the two weeks since Trump left hospital and has intensified since last Thursday's (Friday AEDT) final debate between the two candidates. It's being supercharged by a flurry of splashy supporter rallies that has reawakened memories of four years ago.

-----

https://www.afr.com/world/north-america/i-was-a-lot-more-confident-three-weeks-ago-20201028-p569i0

'I was a lot more confident three weeks ago'

Oct 29, 2020 – 12.00am

Former US correspondent John Kehoe spoke with Washington correspondent Jacob Greber this week about the tightening race to the White House.

In this interview they cover:

  • The mood on the ground. "You can feel it with people you meet, it's all on the line when it comes to this vote, there is no in between."
  • The very different campaigns. "There is a massive contrast in the campaigns....and the danger is Trump looks more hungry."
  • Whether the polls can be trusted this time. "The same patterns are emerging four years later...Biden is slightly better off but that's not a lot."
  • The states to watch. "Ohio is a must-win for Trump."
  • The impact of the coronavirus pandemic. "There's forecasts by early January you will have 400,000 people dead. I don't know how an economy recovers from that."
  • The impact on financial markets. "Biden has big, ambitious plans, he wants to spend $US2 trillion in the green energy space which is good news for a bunch of Australian companies."
  • The fight for control of the Senate. "There's a bunch of races that are incredibly tight."
  • Who will win. "I was a lot more confident three weeks ago, I thought it would be Biden in a landslide."

Kehoe and Greber will be back next Thursday, the day after the election for all the fallout.

-----

https://www.smh.com.au/world/europe/overwhelmed-germany-france-return-to-lockdown-as-virus-cases-soar-in-europe-20201029-p569jz.html

'Overwhelmed': Germany, France return to lockdown as virus cases soar in Europe

By Bevan Shields

October 29, 2020 — 6.56am

London: Europe is bracing for a new spate of national lockdowns as COVID-19 surges across the continent and threatens to fill hospitals with more patients than the first deadly wave of earlier this year.

German Chancellor Angela Merkel and French President Emmanuel Macron on Wednesday announced fresh lockdowns to bring down the rapidly growing number of infections, hospitalisations and deaths in each country.

The decisions mark a milestone in Europe's battle with the disease because governments had until now resisted the sort of mass closures ordered during the outbreak of March and April.

In an address to the nation, Macron said France had been "overwhelmed" and warned the second wave would kill more people over winter than 30,000 who died in the spring.

He said avoiding a lockdown was not acceptable because it would kill 400,000 citizens.

-----

https://www.smh.com.au/business/markets/investors-fearing-a-catastrophic-market-crash-more-than-they-have-in-years-20201026-p568hu.html

Investors fearing a catastrophic market crash more than they have in years

By Robert J. Shiller

October 29, 2020 — 7.40am

The coronavirus crisis and the November election have driven fears of a major market crash to the highest levels in many years.

At the same time, stocks are trading at very high levels. That volatile combination doesn't mean that a crash will occur, but it suggests that the risk of one is relatively high. This is a time to be careful.

I base these conclusions largely on research I've been doing for years, including findings from the stock market confidence indexes that I began to develop more than three decades ago. These indexes are drawn from surveys of a random sample of high-income individual investors and institutional investors in the United States that are now conducted monthly by the International Centre for Finance at the Yale School of Management.

Consider what my Crash Confidence Index is telling us. That measurement of sentiment about the safety of the stock market is based on this question:

"What do you think is the probability of a catastrophic stock market crash in the US, like that of October 28, 1929, or October 19, 1987, in the next six months, including the case that a crash occurred in the other countries and spreads to the US?"

-----

https://www.theaustralian.com.au/business/the-wall-street-journal/what-in-the-world-if-trump-wins/news-story/7aab33ad1438e42c4dfaada3745c1c47

What in the world if Trump wins?

Walter Russell Mead

The odds are against him again, but Donald Trump has every intention of winning four more years in office. In foreign policy at least, his second term would likely be even more transformative and unconventional than his first.

Most second-term presidents look to make a mark in foreign policy. This is partly because a president’s political clout at home diminishes as the definitive end of his mandate approaches, while overseas a president has a relatively free hand even at the end of a second term. So commanders in chief often go looking for diplomatic breakthroughs.

Bill Clinton and George W. Bush both devoted great efforts to getting an Israeli-Palestinian agreement in their second terms. Barack Obama signed the Iran deal and the Paris Climate Accords. As unconventional a figure as Mr Trump is, he is likely to look for trophy achievements overseas too.

Second-term presidents have another important trait: They tend to trust their instincts more. Getting elected once might mean you are lucky; getting elected twice must mean you are good.

-----

https://www.theaustralian.com.au/world/us-election-opinion-polls-paint-a-different-picture-after-quick-fix/news-story/7a704a2bb7060a9576df9f2e5bd1e67a

US election opinion polls paint a different picture after quick fix

CAMERON STEWART

On the election trail, the first thing almost every Donald Trump supporter tells me is that they don’t believe the polls that show Joe Biden is leading.

“The polls were wrong in 2016 and they’ll be wrong again,” they say. So you don’t believe that Biden is ahead of Trump by more than seven points nationally? I ask. “No way. Not even close. Trump is a landslide.”

The polling industry in the US is still recovering from the historic black eye it received in 2016 when the polls fooled people into thinking Hillary Clinton would defeat Trump.

Since then pollsters have been trying to improve their poll methods so that this 2020 election gets it right and restores faith in the very notion of political polls.

-----

https://www.afr.com/world/north-america/trump-to-use-misleading-gdp-data-for-last-ditch-voter-appeal-20201029-p569oa

Trump to use misleading GDP data in 11th-hour voter pitch

Donald Trump, who is desperately seeking to close a persistent polling gap to Joe Biden, has already taken credit for the third-quarter bounce, crowing that it will be the biggest on record. The calculations, however, hide a grim truth.

Jacob Greber United States correspondent

Updated Oct 29, 2020 – 5.02pm, first published at 5.00pm

Washington | A partial rebound in third-quarter economic growth late on Thursday (AEDT) will give Donald Trump bragging rights in the final days of the 2020 campaign, while at the same time confirming the world's biggest economy is struggling to regain momentum as COVID-19 rates spike and the deadweight loss of the President's tariff wars linger.

America, which is still wedded to the distorting methodology of "annualising" quarterly gross domestic product numbers, is likely to be flooded by headlines showing the economy expanded by an eye-popping 32 per cent in the September quarter, after shrinking 31.4 per cent in the previous three months.

Translated to terms Australians recognise, that equates to a quarter-on-quarter GDP increase of about 7.2 per cent in the wake of the second quarter's 9 per cent contraction.

For context, it's worth noting that prior to the pandemic the US economy grew at an annualised rate of between 2 and 3 per cent. Even after the third quarter's surge, GDP will probably be 4 per cent below its pre-crisis peak, forecasters say.

-----

https://www.smh.com.au/world/europe/france-church-attack-suspect-had-been-expelled-from-italy-weeks-ago-20201030-p569yf.html

France church attack suspect had been expelled from Italy weeks ago

By Nick Squires

October 30, 2020 — 8.00am

Rome: The 21-year-old Tunisian Nice attack suspect arrived in France via the Italian island of Lampedusa only a few weeks ago, sources close to the inquiry said.

The revelation that Brahim Aouissaoui, the suspect, landed in late September on the tiny island south of Sicily sparked a major political row in Italy.

Italian authorities reportedly placed him in quarantine for two weeks on board a ship, the Rhapsody.

He was interviewed by immigration officials on October 8, Italian media reported last night. But they released him, giving him an expulsion order and telling him to leave Italy.

Instead, he travelled to the southern city of Bari, in the region of Puglia, and from there made his way to France in early October. It was reported that the French authorities identified him from a document he had been given by the Italian Red Cross.

-----

https://www.smh.com.au/business/the-economy/the-world-s-largest-economy-was-hit-by-a-bus-it-s-healing-but-slowly-20201030-p569yj.html

The world's largest economy was hit by a bus. It’s healing, but slowly.

By Neil Irwin

October 30, 2020 — 7.34am

To understand what the latest numbers on US gross domestic product are telling us, imagine you are an obsessive sort who takes various measures of your health every day, puts those readings into a spreadsheet, and then every three months averages those daily numbers to get a summary of whether you are getting better or worse.

Then, around mid-March, you're hit by a bus.

You spend the last two weeks of March in a hospital room with catastrophic injuries. But because you had been perfectly healthy for the first 2 1/2 months of the quarter, your average for that quarter shows only a modest worsening of your condition.

The second quarter, though, shows a different story. It covers a time when you were still in the hospital barely able to move (April), and then the time when you were home to begin healing and rehabilitation (May and June). But your average health level for those three months still showed a disaster compared with the first quarter.

Which brings us to the third quarter. The entire period, July through September, represents a time when you are healing. Gone are the days when you were confined to a hospital bed; you can move around a little bit, regain some strength in atrophied limbs, cut back on pain medication.

-----

https://www.theaustralian.com.au/world/two-killed-in-knife-attack-at-church-in-nice/news-story/93ce737113ae639be7e5a7ab2ec02724

France raises attack alert after knifeman kills three at church

Jacquelin Magnay

France has raised its terror alert to the highest level following the brutal killing of three people inside a Nice church on the Côte d’Azure.

Amid escalating tensions between France and the Muslim world, the scene at the Notre Dame Basilica overnight (AEDT) was described by police as “a vision of horror”.

A 21-year-old Tunisian migrant, Brahim Aoussaoui, rampaged inside the church, screaming “Allahu Akbar” as he beheaded a 70-year-old parishioner and then fatally stabbed a 45-year-old church warden Vincent Loques. According to French reports, Aoussaoui arrived in Europe just a few weeks ago.

A third victim, a woman aged about 40, was also stabbed inside the church but fled to an adjacent cafe where she died of her injuries. Her heartbreaking last words were later made public.

-----

https://www.theaustralian.com.au/world/china-plots-its-path-to-2035/news-story/38f20aaf9b3568beeaadd91ccc823adc

China plots its path to 2035

Will Glasgow

The elite of the Chinese Communist Party has announced a vision for China in 2035 that will be stronger, richer and possibly still led by General Secretary Xi Jinping.

Days before the US presidential election, the Party’s central committee concluded a pivotal four-day, closed-door meeting in Beijing to plot China’s 2021-25 five year plan and the outlook to 2035.

The entire post-meeting communique was read for 30 minutes on Thursday evening on the state broadcaster China Central Television, a sign of its importance in the country’s highly organised political system.

The communique traditionally offers guidance of the policy focus of the more detailed five-year-plan, which is expected to be released at the National People’s Congress next March.

-----

https://www.theaustralian.com.au/nation/the-global-debt-pile-will-grow-by-us20-trillion-this-year-sp-says/news-story/2bac655cfc345c99c96b509910b46cb3

The global debt pile will grow by $US20 trillion this year, S&P says

Patrick Commins

The world’s debt burden will surge to a record $US200 trillion this year, or almost 260 per cent of total global economic output, Standard & Poor’s says.

In a new report, the ratings agency said borrowing by governments, businesses and households through the COVID-19 recession will lift total debt by 10 per cent in 2020, before levelling off in coming years as an expected recovery takes hold.

Despite surging debt around the world, S&P said “a near-term debt crisis will likely be averted” provided economic activity lifts and rates stay low and finance easy to attain.

S&P said its forecast for “a continuing, albeit choppy, global economic recovery” was predicated on a vaccine becoming available from mid-2021.

In Australia, total gross debt will lift by 19 percentage points to 251 per cent of GDP by the end of this year. Household borrowings will stay relatively steady at a lofty 125 per cent of output, or close to double the global rate.

-----

https://www.theaustralian.com.au/life/how-donald-trump-beat-covid19-with-an-experimental-cocktail-of-drugs/news-story/ac0bca230a5330454adc3b778456bb46

How Trump beat Covid-19

Doctors ‘threw the kitchen sink’ at Donald Trump when treating him for the virus. Researchers are trying to work out how to treat the rest of us.

By Natasha Robinson

When US President Donald Trump contracted coronavirus, many were pessimistic about his chances of making a quick recovery. At 74, Trump’s risk of death was elevated. He is 190cm tall and weighs 111kg, putting him in the obese range, another risk factor for severe disease.

When Trump appeared to make a speedy recovery from COVID-19 after spending only three days in hospital, he credited an experimental antibody cocktail with his return to health and proclaimed that he wanted all Americans who fell ill with coronavirus to be given the same treatment.

It’s impossible to know whether the investigational antibody cocktail that Trump was given — developed by US biotech Regeneron Pharmaceuticals — reduced the severity of the President’s illness. Trump also took the corticosteroid dexamethasone, and the antiviral drug remdesivir, as well as zinc, vitamin D, the heartburn medication famotidine, melatonin and aspirin.

“They threw the kitchen sink at the guy,” says Australian immunologist John Dwyer.

There’s good evidence that dexamethasone reduces mortality rates, and some evidence that remdesivir reduces illness duration by a modest amount. Antibody treatments have shown promising ­results in test tube studies, but clinical trials are yet to prove the efficacy of the cutting-edge ­therapy.

-----

https://www.afr.com/world/north-america/america-is-holding-its-breath-20201030-p569zu

America is holding its breath

After four years of Trump, a presidential race that has robbed the experts of all their confidence may be this year's biggest “October Surprise”.

Jacob Greber United States correspondent

Oct 31, 2020 – 12.00am

The weather reports look good. Election Day next Tuesday (Wednesday AEDT) will dawn sunny and warm in Florida, Texas, Georgia, Arizona, Nevada and North Carolina.

Further north, in Ohio, Pennsylvania and Michigan, there will be a seasonal chill. But the sun will be out to keep the edge off. There are no hurricanes in the immediate forecast. No windstorms. No Arctic blasts.

In other words, the deck is clear across America. November 3 will be as fine a day as you’d possibly want for voting. Especially in those states that matter.

After almost four years of continuous campaigning by Donald Trump, an interminable and tortuous Democratic primary that saw the party opt for a fading stalwart, a presidential impeachment, Russian interference, an ongoing pandemic that has killed 230,000 and counting, and a crashed and now partially recovered economy, the race for the White House is coming down to the intangibles like whether snow or rain keeps voters at home.

It’s been an epic marathon, centred almost entirely on a single character – Donald Trump. And it began the day he was elected four years ago.

-----

https://www.afr.com/world/north-america/trumpism-has-taken-over-what-is-the-future-of-the-gop-20201030-p569yq

Trumpism has taken over; What is the future of the GOP?

Win or lose next week, the Trump family will continue rallying their white working-class fans around the country for the next four years.

Joe Aston Columnist

Updated Oct 30, 2020 – 11.35am, first published at 10.45am

Donald Trump jnr appeared on Sean Hannity’s Fox News program on Wednesday (Thursday AEDT) fresh from headlining a Make America Great Again rally for 3000 people in Vero Beach, Florida.

“I love how the son of the president gets a big crowd too,” Hannity marvelled. “Maybe that’s a harbinger of things to come?”

“I’d like to think so,” the 42-year-old conceded.

Whether President Trump navigates a second narrow election victory next week or leaves Washington DC on January 20 a repudiated man, the Republican Party he remade four years ago is about to undergo some level of bracing renewal.

Inevitably, electoral defeat for the President will cause maximum upheaval in conservative politics, leaving the base to coalesce around national leadership aspirants such as former UN ambassador Nikki Haley, Fox News host Tucker Carlson, a host of Republican senators and yes, even Donald jnr.

-----

https://www.smh.com.au/world/asia/china-s-five-year-plan-keeps-us-ties-and-talks-up-peace-20201030-p56a5m.html

China's five-year plan keeps US ties and talks up peace

By Eryk Bagshaw

October 30, 2020 — 5.01pm

The Chinese Communist Party has emerged from days of secretive meetings to declare it has no interest in severing economic ties with the United States, will ramp up investment in renewable technology and pursue a peaceful unification with Taiwan.

Laying out its plans for the next five years, the Chinese Communist Party's Central Committee hosted a rare press conference on Friday to put innovation at the top of China's agenda for the first time, signalling it will pursue home-grown technology to protect itself from international tensions at the same time as it calls for renewed engagement with the US.

Han Wenxiu, the Party's deputy director of the Office of Financial Affairs, said links between China and the US were shaped by their complimentary economies.

"Complete decoupling is not realistic at all," he said, pointing to data that showed that trade between the superpowers had grown by 16 per cent in the September quarter. "It is not good for China, the US and the whole world."

-----

https://www.theaustralian.com.au/inquirer/us-election-2020-global-stability-needs-change-in-white-house/news-story/22b85698d70e0adad183b24f578add4f

US election 2020: Global stability needs change in White House

Paul Kelly

This week’s 2020 American election will be a transforming event — for the United States, for democracy and for the world. Donald Trump and Joe Biden are contrasting candidates separated by values, style and substance, putting America at a turning point.

There is no return to the pre-2016 world before the Trump Revolution. America is engulfed in an internal schism with almost no prospect of domestic stability post-election. The forces driving fundamental change cannot be denied — the failure of governing elites over the previous 15 years, the intensity of the populist revolt that Trump exploited, the dimensions of the China challenge and the destruction wrought by COVID-19 sure to extend into the 2020s.

Trump and Biden bring a conflicting ideological outlook to this uncertain world. A Trump victory will constitute one of the most remarkable recoveries in US political history — in defiance of the coronavirus, the polls, the media, the liberal establishment, institutional power from New York to California and despite a campaign that largely abandoned any disciplined and cohesive strategy.

Such a victory will see Trump unleashed. It will be an unprecedented spectacle — Trump vindicated, raging in celebration, his visceral instincts triumphant, his opponents vanquished, Biden following Hillary Clinton as another loser, the American progressive movement facing its darkest night and the greatest narcissist to occupy the White House rewarded in his narcissism. In this scenario Trump would double down.

-----

https://www.theaustralian.com.au/nation/chinas-need-for-our-iron-ore-a-nightmare/news-story/7cc7c44ce9be0e034e2fafaf5397c707

China’s need for our iron ore a ‘nightmare’

Geoff Raby is a former Australian Ambassador to China.

Will Glasgow

China’s dependence on Australian iron ore and other key resources is a “nightmare” for its strategic and defence planners, according to Australia’s former China ambassador, Geoff Raby.

Beijing’s anxieties — irrespective of its relationship with Canberra — will see the more than $60bn-a-year export shrink in coming years, Mr Raby, who was previously a board member on iron ore mining giant Fortescue Metals Group, said.

“For normal strategic risk mitigation, China will seek to diversify its iron ore sources. It goes beyond the state of the bilateral relationship,” Mr Raby said.

“Any strategic planner will not want to be as dependent on one country — especially the closest ally of the United States — for one its most critical raw materials.” Beijing’s acute anxiety over its resource dependency is a key reason the former ambassador argues China is a “constrained superpower” in his book “China’s Grand Strategy and Australia’s Future in the New Global Order”.

-----

https://www.theaustralian.com.au/inquirer/australias-future-is-at-stake-in-the-us-election/news-story/f134d8e02f4d6a9eda0ac135e6c89dd8

Australia’s future is at stake in the US election

The US unipolar moment is over and a transition to a new global order is under way. Trump’s victory in 2016 was just a symptom.

By PAUL MONK

Australia has a lot at stake in who wins the looming American presidential election. Donald Trump or Joe Biden, the US unipolar moment is over and a transition to a new global order is under way. Trump’s victory in 2016 was a symptom of this shift in world affairs, not its cause.

While his idiosyncrasies have disconcerted many people, they have dramatised the basic reality. Consequently, Australia is having to seriously rethink its national security assumptions and planning. That debate, well under way by 2016, intensified in 2020.

Should Trump be re-elected, the consequences could be cascading. Should Biden win, his administration will face major challenges in rethinking American commitments and alliance structures. It will not have the option of simply making some grandiose declaration that America is “ready to lead again”.

Its leadership has been all but forfeited by Trump, is under direct challenge from China and Russia and needs fundamental institutional rebalancing, if it is to underpin a viable global order in the 2020s.

-----

https://www.afr.com/world/europe/england-to-enter-new-lockdown-20201101-p56afl

England to enter new lockdown

Jill Lawless

Nov 1, 2020 – 8.05am

London| British Prime Minister Boris Johnson on Saturday announced a new month-long lockdown for England after being warned that without tough action a resurgent coronavirus outbreak will overwhelm hospitals in weeks.

On the day the UK passed 1 million confirmed COVID-19 cases, Mr Johnson made a sudden about-face and confirmed that stringent restrictions on business and daily life would begin Thursday and last until December 2.

He said at a televised news conference that “no responsible prime minister” could ignore the grim figures.

“Unless we act, we could see deaths in this country running at several thousand a day,” said Mr Johnson, who was hospitalised earlier this year for a serious case of COVID-19.

-----

https://www.smh.com.au/world/europe/panicked-johnson-orders-new-lockdown-second-wave-on-course-to-kill-85-000-20201031-p56aem.html

Panicked Johnson orders new lockdown, second wave on course to kill 85,000

By Bevan Shields

November 1, 2020 — 7.03am

London: Prime Minister Boris Johnson has ordered a sweeping national lockdown after being told the second wave striking England is more severe than the government's worst-case scenario forecasts and could collapse the health system.

"Unless we act, we could see deaths in this country running at several thousand a day," Johnson said in a hastily convened press conference on Saturday night. "No responsible prime minister can ignore the message of those figures."

Sunday, November 1: England will go back into lockdown until at least December, Boris Johnson has announced, as coronavirus cases surge past 1 million.

The government believes the disease could kill 85,000 people in Britain over winter - on top of the 60,000 who have died since the pandemic began earlier this year.

-----

https://www.smh.com.au/world/oceania/nz-votes-yes-to-euthanasia-no-to-legalising-cannabis-20201030-p56a3m.html

New Zealanders vote 'yes' to euthanasia, 'no' to legalising cannabis

By James Massola

Updated October 30, 2020 — 3.40pmfirst published at 12.28pm

Two-thirds of New Zealand voters have chosen to legalise euthanasia, but a push to legalise marijuana for recreational use has been narrowly defeated.

The country's election commission on Friday released the preliminary results of two referendums held on the same day as the October 17 parliamentary election.

Of the 2,415,547 people who cast ballots, 65.2 per cent voted to support the End of Life Choice Act 2019 — the euthanasia bill — which will now come into effect on November 6, 2021.

But the push to legalise recreational cannabis and allow it to be grown and sold under controlled circumstances was defeated. The "yes" vote had 46.1 per cent support while 53.1 per cent of people voted "no".

-----

https://www.smh.com.au/business/the-economy/don-t-get-too-fixated-on-trump-s-america-we-trade-much-more-with-others-20201030-p56a7p.html

Don't get too fixated on Trump's America. We trade much more with others

Matt Wade

Senior economics writer

November 1, 2020 — 12.05am

America’s election drama has us hooked.

The big audiences reading story after story about US politics on the websites of The Sydney Morning Herald and The Age show how fixated Australia has become with Tuesday’s presidential ballot.

I know Donald Trump is hard to ignore. But might we be paying just a bit too much attention?

It's true the US is still the world’s biggest economy. Yes, America is Australia’s most important ally. And sure, our two nations have deep cultural links.

But our fixation on Trump’s America is not matched by our trade with the US.

Throughout the 1980s and much of the 1990s, the US consistently purchased more than 10 per cent of Australia’s exports, but that share has declined steadily since the turn of the century.

-----

https://www.theaustralian.com.au/world/us-election-2020-trump-warns-of-bedlam-without-a-clear-result-on-election-night/news-story/427df491c642e65936a75ec7f0339614

US election 2020: Trump warns of ‘bedlam’ without a clear result on election night

Cameron Stewart

Donald Trump has warned of ‘bedlam’ in America if there is no clear result on election night, as he and his opponent Joe Biden blitzed key Midwest battleground states with just three days until the poll.

The move came amid a continued surge in early voting with an unprecedented 90 million votes already cast by mail or person - two thirds of the total votes cast in the 2016 election.

It also came as new coronavirus cases jumped to a record 100,000 cases a day, giving a boost to Mr Biden who has accused the president of fatally mishandling the panic which has claimed more than 230,000 lives.

Mr Trump held four rallies in the key swing state of Pennsylvania on Sunday (AEDT), accusing the former vice president of threatening thousands of jobs in the state with his opposition to fossil fuels and fracking.

-----

I look forward to comments on all this!

-----

David.

 

It Seems The Further You Are Away From The ADHA The More Clearly You Can See Things

 This appeared a few days ago:

Five minutes with Mitchell Burger

This month we spent five minutes with Mitchell Burger, Director Strategy, Architecture, Innovation and Research, ICT Services, in Sydney Local Health District.

- Introductory stuff omitted.-

What do you think will enable digital health projects and innovations to succeed?
We are about to start consultation to develop our district’s new 5-year digital health strategy, and have done a little thinking on this, so here is a long (sorry!) list of bullet points. We’d really love suggestions.

  • Genuine partnership with clinicians and the community in the codesign and implementation of new, digitally-enabled models of care – something akin to the Yolngu concept of Ganma
  • Focusing on workforce development as a priority over technology – both building specialisations like informatics and data science and analytics, and also upskilling and promoting the slow and steady process of cultural change across the broader workforce
  • Carving out protected time and spaces for clinicians to reimagine workflows and design and iterate new models of care in partnership with digital health disciplines
  • Re-apportioning of government and health service budgets into digital infrastructure and transformation programs, commensurate with its emerging criticality and contribution to population health and growing business value (say, by benchmarking investment in digital as a proportion of CAPEX and OPEX to other sectors). And mimicking, say, long-term investment models like justice reinvestment and NZ’s welfare budget.
  • Inclusion of sustainable funding mechanisms for new models of care by design, upfront
  • Research operationalisation and streamlining innovation and procurement pathways, to accelerate research translation and give proofs of concept and pilot projects defined and well-trodden paths to production and scale
  • Fostering and continuing to develop expertise in implementation science within regional health services
  • Investment in foundational digital infrastructure (esp. data systems infrastructure) and institutional competencies that will enable a longer-term transition to value-based care and away from activity-based funding, and also enable us to leverage emerging AI and automation technologies
  • Piloting regional commissioning partnerships between LHDs and PHNs using pooled, blended capitation and outcomes-based funding mechanisms (e.g. like the Prevention and Chronic Condition Management Funds (PCCMF) recommended by the Productivity Commission)
  • My view (and I’m open to feedback!) is that we should reconsider interoperability as a microeconomic challenge, rather than a technical one, and that health services could accelerate interoperability through taking a much harder line in procurement and leveraging our near-monopoly market positions to instigate standards adoption and promote use of digital solutions like eRef, My Health Record, secure messaging, etc. within regional digital ecosystems

A final thought: I think that hospital districts, together with PHNs, are uniquely placed through their scale, community and cross-sectoral partnerships, public trust, and sovereignty over clinical and data governance to be at the forefront of digital transformation.

What do you think are the biggest challenges facing digital health at the moment?
Digital health is of course very hard, and there are many challenges, so it takes resilience and energy. Here is another long list of some immediate challenges – again, we’d be delighted to receive suggestions for how to address these, so please reach out.

  • The sheer complexity of implementations, and the speed of technological development
  • Poor, stagnant design and usability of clinical information systems, which don’t meet modern digital service standards
  • Hype, and an overly future-oriented mindset beset with management jargon and technocrats (like me I have to admit!) chasing the next idea rather than seeing things through
  • Disillusionment resulting from unfulfilled promise and overly optimistic digital and ICT business cases
  • Eroding social licence for use of health data
  • Legacy funding models which do not reward and foster innovation
  • Data availability and data quality
  • Institutional competence in data governance, privacy and cyber security
  • Ambiguity in roles and responsibilities for digital initiatives between the different levels of government

Do you have any interesting resources or helpful networks people should know about?
For those interested in some of the issues surrounding the use of AI – I think the AI Now Institute is a fantastic resource. And I have a huge Endnote library full of reports and articles on AI, only a very tiny fraction of which I’ve actually read (optimistically I try to think of it as an antilibrary!), so I’d be happy to share this too.

Connect with Mitchell via LinkedIn

Here is the link:

https://dhin.net.au/five-minutes-with-mitchell-burger/

Isn’t nice to read about Digital Health from someone who does not think that more adoption of the #myHR is the answer to everything. Clearly the brainwashing can wear off!

David.

Wednesday, November 04, 2020

The Office Of The Australian Information Commissioner Has Had A Busy Week Or Two.

For a quick review of what they do – here is the homepage link:

https://www.oaic.gov.au/

In terms of what is going on we had 2 interesting reports.

First this:

Privacy Act review to examine privacy tort, direct action rights, and GDPR compliance

The Attorney-General's Department will look at carve-outs, harmonisation with states and other nations, and a right to erase for Australians.

By Chris Duckett | October 30, 2020 -- 06:19 GMT (17:19 AEDT) | Topic: Security

Australia's Attorney-General Christian Porter announced on Friday the terms of reference and issues paper that his department will use as a basis for its review of the Privacy Act.

The wide-ranging review will consider the definition of personal information; whether existing exemptions for small businesses, political parties, and the storing of employee records to comply with the Act should remain; whether individuals should gain the power to drag privacy violators to court; and whether a privacy tort should be created.

The review was agreed to as part of the Commonwealth's response to the Australian Competition and Consumer Commission's (ACCC) Digital Platforms Inquiry.

In posing 67 questions for submissions to respond to, the Attorney-General's Department (AGD) has asked whether the definition of personal information should be extended to inferred personal information as well as whether additional protections should be extended to de-identified, anonymised, and pseudonymised information.

Of particular interest in the paper was the failure of Australian privacy laws to be compatible with those in Europe, especially the General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR), with exemptions created in the Australian law two decades ago being a roadblock.

"The [Australian Law Reform Commission (ALRC)] noted that no other comparable jurisdiction (the United Kingdom, New Zealand, Canada, and the European Union) exempts small businesses from the general privacy law," the paper said.

"The Senate Committee inquiry further recommended the removal of the exemption given the privacy regimes in overseas jurisdictions have operated effectively without a small business exemption and that the existence of the exemption was one of the key outstanding issues preventing Australia from seeking adequacy with the EU.

"[The ALRC] also noted that the United Kingdom does not exempt employee records and that removing the exemption may facilitate recognition of the adequacy of Australian privacy law by the EU."

On the flip side, the paper pointed out that only UK and Germany were in Australia's top 15 two-way trading partners while other economies around the Asia-Pacific made up 72% of trade. The EU only accounted for 13.5%.

"As less trade is undertaken with the EU than within the APEC region, the government's recent priority has been to ensure adequate privacy protections within and between APEC economies," the AGD said.

"Requiring businesses to comply with different information handling requirements under the Act, [Cross-Border Privacy Rules] and GDPR could result in a regulatory landscape that is overly complex. On the other hand, compliance with the GDPR may give businesses a competitive advantage in engendering consumer trust."

Currently in Australia, if a business has revenue under AU$3 million, it is exempt from the Act, and the paper wrestled with the idea of whether a threshold should remain, and if so, what should it be since businesses under that threshold could handle sensitive personal information yet maintaining the threshold could increase compliance costs for those businesses.

Lots more here:

https://www.zdnet.com/article/privacy-act-review-to-examine-privacy-tort-direct-action-rights-and-gdpr-compliance/

And as a bit of counterpoint we had this:

Privacy office faces ‘remarkable’ drop in funding

Denham Sadler
Senior Reporter

26 October 2020

The federal opposition has questioned a “remarkable” drop in support for the national privacy office in the coming years, with the organisation left waiting on whether government funding will be renewed or if it will face a near-50 per cent cut in resourcing.

The Office of the Australian Information Commissioner (OAIC) was provided $23.565 million in 2020-21 in this month’s federal budget, a slight decrease from the previous year.

There are concerns among privacy and civil rights advocates that the office is “severely underfunded”, despite an increased workload and an increasingly prominent role.

But the OAIC is also facing a potentially significant funding cut in the forward estimates. The budget outlined a small drop to $21.108 million in funding for the 2021-22 financial year, but a significant drop to $13.361 million the following year. This is set to remain stable in 2023-24 at $13.564 million.

This drop in funding is due to the $25.1 million over three years provided to the OAIC in the 2019 budget for privacy complaints coming to an end.

At a Senate Estimates hearing on Thursday, Australian Information Commissioner Angelene Falk confirmed the office is yet to get a funding guarantee for this going forward, but this may be a part of a review of the Privacy Act that is slated to take place soon.

“It will be a matter I continue to work through with the government. As part of that we will be looking at the legislative framework and also my functions and powers in relation to the Privacy Act resourcing that’s required to deliver on any reforms that will be part of the discussions. That needs to occur at that time,” Ms Falk told the Senators.

“That will have a significant impact on the functions of the agency and accordingly I will be in discussions with government well ahead of that time with efforts to ensure that the increased funding received in recent years is continued,” she said.

“There’s a review of the Privacy Act which is imminent and I think this is an opportunity to think about the type of regulator that’s needed in the digital age.”

Another aspect of the apparent funding drop is an OAIC Memorandum of Understanding with the Australian Digital Health Agency for its function overseeing the My Health Record scheme, worth more than $2 million, which is renewed yearly.

Currently, the OAIC will experience a significant funding cut in the 2022-23 financial year unless it is provided further cash.

More here:

https://www.innovationaus.com/privacy-office-faces-remarkable-drop-in-funding/

Interesting that a pretty complex review is underway while the threat of funding cut(s) seems to be very much on the table.

Closer to home we had this appear:

Annual Report of the Australian Information Commissioner’s Activities in Relation to Digital Health 2019–20

Publication date: 2020 (Signed 24 Sept 2020)

Download the print version

Part 1: Executive Summary

This report provides information about the OAIC’s digital health activities, including its assessment program, handling of My Health Record data breach notifications, development of guidance material, provision of advice, and liaison with key stakeholders.

This was the eighth year of operation of the My Health Record system and the tenth year of the Healthcare Identifiers Service (HI Service), a critical enabler for the My Health Record system and digital health generally.

The management of personal information is at the core of both the My Health Record system and the HI Service (which are collectively referred to as ‘digital health’ in this report). In recognition of the special sensitivity of health information, the My Health Records Act and the HI Act contain provisions that protect and restrict the collection, use and disclosure of personal information. The Australian Information Commissioner oversees compliance with those privacy provisions.

The My Health Record system commenced in 2012 as an opt-in system where an individual needed to register in order to get and share their My Health Record. In 2017, the Australian Government announced the creation of a My Health Record for every Australian. Following an opt-out period that ended on 31 January 2019, a My Health Record was created for every Australian who had not opted out of the system.

In 2019–20, the OAIC received 10 privacy complaints relating to the My Health Record system with 1 remaining open at the end of the reporting period. We also finalised 19 complaints from the previous reporting period.

Three privacy complaints were received relating to the HI Service in 2019–20 with 1 remaining open at the end of the reporting period.

Six Commissioner-initiated investigations were opened during the reporting period, 5 of which were finalised with 1 remaining open at the end of the period.

The OAIC received 1 data breach notification in relation to the My Health Record system during 2019–20. This matter was closed at the end of the reporting period.

We also carried out digital health-related work including:

  • commencing 1 privacy assessment, closing 4 privacy assessments and progressing 1 assessment from the reporting period
  • providing advice to stakeholders, including the ADHA and the Department of Health, on privacy- related matters relevant to the My Health Record system
  • updating and promoting guidance materials including the OAIC’s Guide to health privacy
  • monitoring developments in digital health, the My Health Record system and the HI Service.

The much fuller report follows and is found here:

https://www.oaic.gov.au/about-us/our-corporate-information/annual-reports/digital-health-annual-reports/annual-report-of-the-australian-information-commissioners-activities-in-relation-to-digital-health-2019-20/

An interesting item a little further down is that the OAIC receives about $2 Million from the ADHA for regulating privacy of the HI service and the #myHealthRecord.

Overall I find this report rather frustrating as it says the are complaints and issue but does not explain what they are! A bit useless in some aspects I reckon!

As always with an Agency like this there is always some concern about one Agency regulating another – especially when being paid to do it. I am not sure that actually passes the ‘pub test’?

The Privacy Act review looks pretty huge but just how much is about privacy and how much is about commerce is rather an open question. I think I would prefer more person and less commerce in the balance.

David.