Quote Of The Year

Timeless Quotes - Sadly The Late Paul Shetler - "Its not Your Health Record it's a Government Record Of Your Health Information"

or

H. L. Mencken - "For every complex problem there is an answer that is clear, simple, and wrong."

Sunday, April 04, 2021

The ADHA Is Making It All Up Again As Far As Clinical Impact And Success I Reckon.

This extended press release appeared a few days ago.

WA’s Wirraka Maya Health Service leads the way in providing better patient care

Published 31 March 2021

An Aboriginal community health service in Western Australia has produced record results in the use of technology to ensure better connected care for local patients.

Senior Medical Officer at Wirraka Maya Health Service in Port Hedland, WA, Dr Yolande Knight said: “We rely on My Health Record to keep us updated on patient pathology, imaging, medication, dispensing and history records.

“We find it helpful because a lot of our patients are transient, moving from one region to another, so it can be difficult to get their comprehensive files.

“We can see what other doctors have requested and performed, overcoming the delays waiting for records requested from other practices and providers. Equally, we can upload and share what we’ve done, so when the patient attends elsewhere, their record is current and available to other practitioners.

“We can also see what scripts were dispensed. It’s invaluable that PathWest results are automatically available. This helped us a lot with recent COVID-19 test results, where at times it was quicker to see the result on the patient’s record than to join the phone queue to get the result.”

Over 2020, the Wirraka Maya Health Service uploaded the ninth highest number of Shared Health Summaries in Western Australia – this is a summary of a patient’s key health information, and the highest number of Event Summaries in the state  - this is a summary of a key consultation to My Health Record. Also, the health service has viewed more uploaded documents than any other primary care provider in Western Australia.

A key benefit to patients is that they can use the Shared Health Summaries and prescription information that have been uploaded by Wirraka Maya as proof of any underlying health conditions so they can obtain an early Covid-19 vaccination.

Recent changes to My Health Record include a new consolidated view of immunisation information from the Australian Immunisation Register and the individual’s record (shared health summaries and event summaries).

Wirraka Maya Health Service originated from the efforts of Aboriginal people to establish a health service to address the unmet needs of Aboriginal people in the Port Hedland and South Hedland areas and surrounding communities. It commenced the delivery of clinical services in 1996.

The service now has more than 7,000 residents registered and actively engaged in wellbeing, primary care, and prevention programs across the region. 

Hedland is one of three communities across the country currently working with the Australian Digital Health Agency to leverage technology to improve the health and wellbeing of residents.

Australian Digital Health Agency Consumer Advocate, Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Champion and Co-Chair of the Agency’s Reconciliation Working Group and national Medicines Safety Program, Steve Renouf, congratulated Wirraka Maya for its commitment to digital health.

“It’s great to see an Aboriginal-controlled health service leading the way in achieving outstanding results in the use of digital technology,” he said.

“This commitment to digital service delivery will continue to enhance clinical outcomes in local communities and help breach the digital divide that can disadvantage remote patients.”

Aboriginal Health Council of Western Australia (AHCWA) Public Health Medical Officer, Dr Marianne Wood, said: “The Aboriginal Community Controlled Health Services (ACCHS) sector in WA has been a leader in the use of My Health Record and we are very proud of the great work by Wirraka Maya. 

“Many ACCHS recognised, early on, the enormous potential of the record in improving the care of Aboriginal patients, particularly for those who travel widely and receive care from many different health care providers across this enormous state,” she said.

“AHCWA has been very active in supporting both ACCHS and the wider WA health sector in the My Health Record project, recognising that the benefit of the record is far greater when there is a collective effort. The Hedland Community of Excellence Project and the work of Wirraka Maya shows what can be achieved.”

WA Primary Health Alliance General Manager, Primary Care Innovation and Development, Bernadette Kenny, said “This is the result of the whole team at Wirraka Maya working together and understanding the real benefits to their community when it comes to utilising the digital health services available to them.  Their exemplary use of My Health Record ensures their clients are supported throughout their health journey both in the Pilbara and beyond by providing vital clinical information at a time when it is most needed.”

Here is the link:

https://www.digitalhealth.gov.au/newsroom/media-releases/recent-media-releases/was-wirraka-maya-health-service-leads-the-way-in-providing-better-patient-care

Here is the Health Service being discussed.

Wirraka Maya Health Service Aboriginal Corporation

Wirraka Maya Health Service Aboriginal Corporation [ICN 1855] (WMHSAC) is an Aboriginal Community Controlled Health Service designed to ensure our clients' journey through the health system meets their medical, health, social and cultural needs.

WMHSAC originated from the efforts of Aboriginal people to establish a health service that addressed the unmet needs of Aboriginal people in the Port Hedland, South Hedland areas and surrounding communities.

WMHSAC has over 7,000 Aboriginal people registered and are actively engaged and regularly receiving primary care, wellbeing and prevention services and programs. 

We have an experienced team of health professionals, that include Aboriginal Health Workers and Practitioners, GP's and Nurses who work together to improve the health outcomes of Aboriginal people. We also have visiting Specialists and Allied Health Practitioners.  They are supported by the Administrative staff.

Here is the link:

http://www.wmhsac.com/about/about.aspx

The bottom line here is that what we are talking about is a small to medium sized remote General Practice, which has seen a focus from the ADHA in an attempt to justify the #myHR.

But – yet again the core problem of the #myHR being a secondary system comes into play. As Shared summaries are being uploaded, they are clearly being created in another Patient Management System which is obviously the key clinical system in use for patient management, prescribing and so on and which is surely fed more directly by the remote local service providers with results etc.

Also do remember the PBS records are not real-time and are typically delayed by a month or two so access to these might even be misleading.

That is also not the mention the time spent creating copied / duplicate records in a slow user-unfriendly Government system.

The Health Service Aboriginal Health Service (AHS) is serving a registered and presumably relatively stable population and as such there are much better patient management systems available with even some cloud based services available for robustness and resilience!

Yet again we find the ADHA spinning the #myHR as a solution to all that ails you when there are better solutions readily available for a remote AHS that are easier to use, more familiar and more functional than it is.

Oh, don’t forget that yet again, there is no evidence of what difference the #myHR is actually making! It is hardly clear just in what way the AHS leading other than wasting time on the #myHR!

Get off pushing a dud and let’s have some real proposals regarding what may be the proper way forward!

David.

20 comments:

G. Carter said...

Predictably the Federal Government through the Health Record system has become an entrenched obstacle to progress, an inhibitor of innovation and market forces. Even now rather than use ADHA as a first principle way out of its mess it chooses to create a operations team, measured of predictability, repeatability the change resistance brigade never risking an attempt to impact meaningless performance indicators, heavily wedded to ridged process that are followed but not understood or ever questioned. Brittle to the end, and once they inevitably break the result is catastrophic.

A second consequence which goes mostly unnoticed is the continued vendor lock-in and forced workflows driven by technology. With ‘cloud’ emerging this is getting worse. The claim the benefits of cloud but ensure you cannot move between service offerings for a broad range of reasons. Telstra is not buying up because it cares.

Anonymous said...

One day, maybe, just maybe, the full incompetence of the Federal Department, a policy department trying to act like a service delivery agency, will dawn on the people and our politicians:

Our vaccine rollout is a disaster – here’s how to fix it
By Steven Hamilton and Richard Holden
April 5, 2021 — 5.00am
https://www.smh.com.au/national/our-vaccine-rollout-is-a-disaster-here-s-how-to-fix-it-20210404-p57ge7.html

"Australia’s vaccine rollout has so far been an unmitigated disaster. It’s simply untenable for the federal government to continue to pretend it’s going well. We started months after the United States, Britain, the European Union and many others. And now that our long-overdue program has finally begun, we’ve only administered half as many shots per head of population as other countries at the six-week mark."


The comments give hope that the dissatisfaction will grow.

Anonymous said...

A wave of competence would be needed in federal government to admit and address the incompetence - some sort of oxymoron moment.

Anonymous said...

"The bottom line here is that what we are talking about is a small to medium sized remote General Practice, which has seen a focus from the ADHA in an attempt to justify the #myHR."

David, if anyone ever cares to go back 10 or 11 years and dig out the original released specs for the then PCEHR, the description of what the Wirraka Maya Health Service is doing now, is precisely what it was designed for. Yes, each GP practice will still have records in their PMS but the purpose of the Health Record was to be a collection point for all records for a person from all GPs etc they may have seen, so that when they travelled around, information could be easily accessed by the next GP. They may have changed the name, but reading the article about what has been happening in WA, it seems like it is working as originally intended.

Dr David G More MB PhD said...

Read closely and you will see that they are a relatively stable and fixed population so their doc(s) don't really need a $2Billion system that covers the whole country!

To me the PCEHR / MyHR were never fit for purpose as the data was never known to be current, accurate or complete. The design never going to be reliable or useful! was If I worked there at at he AHS I would use the local PMS!

David.

Anonymous said...

The one constant about Federal Health is the hyperbole.

This is what Minister Hunt bragged about in a media release last November

Australia secures a further 50 million doses of COVID-19 vaccine
https://www.health.gov.au/ministers/the-hon-greg-hunt-mp/media/australia-secures-a-further-50-million-doses-of-covid-19-vaccine

"Two more COVID-19 vaccines have been secured for the Australian population under new agreements, bringing the Australian Government’s COVID-19 vaccine investment to more than $3.2 billion.

Under the agreements, Novavax will supply 40 million vaccine doses and Pfizer / BioNTech will provide 10 million vaccine doses, should the vaccines be proven safe and effective.

Prime Minister Scott Morrison said the Government’s COVID-19 Vaccine and Treatment Strategy had now secured access to four COVID-19 vaccines and over 134 million doses.

“By securing multiple COVID-19 vaccines we are giving Australians the best shot at early access to a vaccine, should trials prove successful,” the Prime Minister said."

Notice the use of "secured" and "early access"

Just a reminder, it is reported today that

"The federal government arranged to buy 3.8 million doses of the AstraZeneca vaccine from the EU last September, but has received only 700,000.

Under a separate deal, Australia has received one million doses of the Pfizer vaccine from the EU."

1.7 miilion is a bit short of 134 million.

The USA has already given over 110million jabs and the UK more than 20million.

The Federal government is behaving as though COVID-19 is a political problem, not a health problem. Does this sound familiar?

Anonymous said...

It's just as well that the Department of Health is on the ball, otherwise you might start to believe some amazing things....

"Can COVID-19 vaccines connect me to the internet?

COVID-19 vaccines do not – and cannot – connect you to the internet."

https://www.health.gov.au/initiatives-and-programs/covid-19-vaccines/is-it-true/is-it-true-can-covid-19-vaccines-connect-me-to-the-internet

Although, if they have denied it, maybe it actually is true. Maybe it works via the microchip Bill Gates has developed.

/s

G. Carter said...

AnonymousApril 07, 2021 3:05 PM. If it does then it is by pure chance, the MyHR/PCEHR has been twisted and distorted so far from its original construct that is can only work in small isolated instances and only then if you stand at a certain angle with eyes squinting.

Someone will claim it was built by Alain a because the PHNs align to star clusters in the Orion Nebula.

This might be the start of repositioning the conversation- after ten years of crapping on those who saw health as a distributed system in a distributed business model - a realisation might be happening.

Anonymous said...

See what else the Federal government wants you to know about the COVID-19 vaccine:

What should I do before I get vaccinated for COVID-19?
https://www.health.gov.au/initiatives-and-programs/covid-19-vaccines/learn-about-covid-19-vaccines/what-should-i-do-before-i-get-vaccinated-for-covid-19

You can tell how important they think My Health Record is - not a mention.

All you need do is keep your Medicare details up to date and you can get proof of vaccinations from your Medicare immunisation history through myGov.

Even the Department of Health realises that My Health Record is unreliable and useless. Maybe someone should tell ADHA just how loved they are.

Anonymous said...

Never mind My Health Record, have a look at what Scotty from Marketing thinks about the Minister for Health.

https://www.reddit.com/r/australia/comments/mlr8wq/aussie_pm_makes_freudian_slip_when_referring_to/

Anonymous said...

The world is going technology mad.

This is an example of the logic (or lack of logic):

https://www.australianageingagenda.com.au/technology/calls-to-embed-digital-health-specialist-in-workforce-simplify-aged-care-technology/

This is not what they re saying, just what they mean:

Everyone else is using technology, the aged sector must use technology. We don't know what it is, but we must have it.

If we are going to have all this new beaut techo stuff (which we definitely want), we have to have people trained in it, although we can't tell you what it is, but we can tell you that our people must be trained in it, otherwise we won't be able to use it.

If it weren't so silly it would be funny.

Anonymous said...

Over 75% of transformation fail for very good reasons.

Anonymous said...

If getting 0.6% of ordered doses after 5+ months is early access, I'd hate to see what normal/late access would have given us & by when.

Sarah Conner said...

Well it was all on display this morning. Scotty from Marketing could not hold back his smugness and creepy smile when talking about the unfortunate turn of events for the AstraZeneca vaccine. Clearly all political bets are off and he can reset the targets and clock. It was clear this is simply a political issue and cares little for the other real aspects.

Roll on elections and we can put in place a government that is elected not selected

Anonymous said...

Although she has gone very quiet I thought former Health Department Secretary, Jane Halton, was the national lead for securing Australia's COVID vaccine contracts! What went wrong?

Dr David G More MB PhD said...

I had not heard that - she was involved in reviewing hotel quarantine and in COVAX but have not heard she was involved elsewhere in contracts. Anyone know for sure?

David.

Anonymous said...

https://womensagenda.com.au/latest/jane-halton-ao-is-leading-on-an-international-coalition-to-create-and-fairly-distribute-a-covid-19-vaccine/

https://www.thesaturdaypaper.com.au/news/health/2020/03/28/exclusive-inside-the-hunt-vaccine/15853140009582

https://aicd.companydirectors.com.au/membership/company-director-magazine/2020-back-editions/july/jane-halton--on-covid19-vaccine-development

Anonymous said...

Why does this remind me of the Federal Government and MyHR in particular?

https://i.imgur.com/1I9Q30A.jpg

The inside is not what they tell you on the label.

Anonymous said...

Here they go again.

Australia secures additional Pfizer vaccine following AstraZeneca concerns
https://www.abc.net.au/news/2021-04-09/national-cabinet-astrazeneca-covid-vaccine-clots-rollout/100058440

There's a huge difference between "securing" access to a drug and giving millions of doses to Australians.

"securing access to a vaccine" is in the same category as "registering people for a My Health Record". Meaningless, but sounds good when playing politics.

Anonymous said...

Scott Morrison- Australia’s boy who cried wolf.